HEALTH OUTCOMES OF INCARCERATED PREGNANT WOMEN
AND THEIR INFANTS IN A COMMUNITY-BASED PROGRAM
Violet H. Barkauskas, PhD, RN, Lisa Kane Low, CNM, PhD and Sheryl Pimlott, MSW, PhD(c)
An experimental, community-based, residential program, fo-
cused on health promotion, was established in 1990 for
incarcerated pregnant women with short-term sentences and
histories of drug abuse in a large, midwestern metropolitan area
in the United States. Infants resided with mothers after birth.
Prenatal care, delivery, postpartum, and family-planning ser-
vices were initiated and provided by a nurse-midwifery service.
Community-based health care, job training, and drug rehabili-
tation were provided for women during pregnancy through the
fourth postpartum month. Program participants’ prenatal, de-
livery, postpartum, and neonatal health outcomes are presented
and compared with those of incarcerated women in the same
state prison system who experienced usual correctional facility
care and support. Program participants represented a group of
obstetrically high-risk women. Health outcomes for both
groups of incarcerated women and their infants were similar
and more optimal than would have been expected given their
preexisting health conditions and risk factors. J Midwifery
Womens Health 2002;47:371–9 © 2002 by the American
College of Nurse-Midwives.
INTRODUCTION
Incarcerated women are a medically high-risk group
because of their preincarceration lifestyles, health prob-
lems, and related environmental influences (1–5). In
1998, Henderson (6) conducted a comprehensive review
of the available literature on incarcerated women’s health
and concluded that incarcerated women demonstrate an
excess of drug abuse, mental health problems, and
physical and sexual abuse. As stated by Safyer and
Richmond (7) in a 1995 review of the course of preg-
nancy in women who are incarcerated: “With so many of
the prison population from backgrounds of poverty,
violence, and drug use, and with limited access to health
care in their communities, it is to be expected that women
behind bars suffer from a broad range of health prob-
lems.”
In 1996, approximately 138,000 women were impris-
oned in the United States (8), of which an estimated 25%
were pregnant upon incarceration or had delivered in the
past year (7). Approximately 64% of incarcerated women
are mothers of dependent children (6). The health care
needs of female prisoners in general, and pregnant
prisoners in particular, challenge the traditional models
of health care provided within prisons. In response to
those challenges, a special residential program for preg-
nant, drug-dependent women was established in 1990 as
an option within a midwestern state’s corrections system.
The purpose of this article is to describe the development
of the residential program and to present data about
selected program health outcomes during the most recent
program years, 1996 –1999. The health outcome study
was part of a larger program evaluation that also exam-
ined the mental health of the mothers before, during, and
upon completion of residential program treatment; as-
sessed mothers’ long-term stability in the community
after discharge via follow-up interviews at 6 months and
1 year after release; and evaluated the interaction of
residential program mothers with their infants.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Various studies have explored the effects of incarceration
on maternal and infant health. Reports have described
deliveries without adequate assistance or in shackles, as
well as difficult separations of mothers and infants
(9,10). As prison health care has become more humane,
reports of maternity care outcomes in prison populations
have been more favorable, especially considering the
high-risk health status of most incarcerated pregnant
women (11–14).
Many arrests of women are drug related, and studies
have documented that most female arrestees test positive
for illicit drugs (15). Cordero and colleagues (16) studied
233 incarcerated pregnant women receiving care in a
comprehensive prenatal care program in Ohio. Seventy-
one percent of the women had drug abuse problems, 70%
smoked, and 21% had other medical problems. In this
sample, the cesarean section rate was 16%. Adverse
infant outcomes included a 3% prematurity rate, and 8%
were assessed as being small for gestational age. Egley
and colleagues (17) compared 69 incarcerated women
with nonincarcerated controls, matched for age, parity,
race, and date of prenatal care entry. In the incarcerated
sample, 36% of the women had abused drugs and 68%
smoked. The outcomes in both groups were similar: 12%
of the infants had low birth weight, and 8.5% required
intensive care. Mertens (18) studied a sample of 71
pregnant inmates in a large county jail setting. In this
Address correspondence to Violet H. Barkauskas, 400 North Ingalls,
Ann Arbor, MI 48109-0482.
Journal of Midwifery & Women’s Health • Vol. 47, No. 5, September/October 2002 371
© 2002 by the American College of Nurse-Midwives 1526-9523/02/$22.00 • PII S1526-9523(02)00279-9
Issued by Elsevier Science Inc.