Dimensionless Equation of State to Predict Microemulsion Phase
Behavior
Soumyadeep Ghosh and Russell T. Johns*
Department of Energy and Mineral Engineering, College of Earth and Mineral Sciences, The Pennsylvania State University,
University Park, Pennsylvania 16802, United States
ABSTRACT: Prediction of microemulsion phase behavior for changing
state variables is critical to formulation design of surfactant-oil-brine
(SOB) systems. SOB systems find applications in various chemical and
petroleum processes, including enhanced oil recovery. A dimensional
equation-of-state (EoS) was recently presented by Ghosh and Johns
1
that
relied on estimation of the surfactant tail length and surface area. We give
an algorithm for flash calculations for estimation of three-phase Winsor
regions that is more robust, simpler, and noniterative by making the
equations dimensionless so that estimates of tail length and surface area
are no longer needed. We predict phase behavior as a function
temperature, pressure, volume, salinity, oil type, oil-water ratio, and
surfactant/alcohol concentration. The dimensionless EoS is based on
coupling the HLD-NAC (Hydrophilic Lipophilic Difference-Net Average
Curvature) equations with new relationships between optimum salinity and solubility. An updated HLD expression that includes
pressure is also used to complete the state description. A significant advantage of the dimensionless form of the EoS over the
dimensional version is that salinity scans are tuned based only on one parameter, the interfacial volume ratio. Further, stability
conditions are developed in a simplified way to predict whether an overall compositions lies within the single, two-, or three-
phase regions. Important new microemulsion relationships are also found, the most important of which is that optimum
solubilization ratio is equal to the harmonic mean of the oil and water solubilization ratios in the type III region. Thus, only one
experimental measurement is needed in the three-phase zone to estimate the optimum solubilization ratio, a result which can aid
experimental design and improve estimates of optimum from noisy data. Predictions with changing state variables are illustrated
by comparison to experimental data using standard diagrams including a new type of dimensionless fish plot. The results show
that the optimum solubilization ratio and salinity using the tuned dimensionless EoS are within average errors of 2.44% and
1.17% of experimental values for the fluids examined. We then use the dimensionless equations and thermodynamic first-
principles to derive the constant in Huh’s equation for interfacial tension prediction.
■
INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND
Microemulsions are homogeneous solutions consisting of
surfactant, oil, and brine (SOB). The term was first introduced
by Hoar and Schulman who found that, by titration of a milky
emulsion containing potassium oleate (a soap) with a medium-
chain alcohol (pentanol or hexanol), a stable oil-in-water
emulsion was produced.
2
Winsor later described micro-
emulsions as swollen micellar solutions.
3
Broadly, micelles
(surfactant aggregates in aqueous solution), macroemulsions
(or simple emulsions), and microemulsions (also known as
micellar solutions) can be categorized by the dimensions of the
dispersed phase. Microemulsions can have low interfacial
tensions that result in negative Gibbs free energy of emulsion
formation, which implies microemulsions are formed sponta-
neously and are thermodynamically stable.
4
The affinity of a surfactant toward the oil or water phase is a
function of the surfactant type, composition, and state of the
system. Winsor introduced the concept of the R-ratio to explain
the balance between the surfactant’s oil and water affinity.
5
Three distinct regions near the interface are defined: an
aqueous region (W), a nonpolar oleic region (O), and an
amphiphilic or bridging region (C). The interfacial zone (C) is
of a fixed thickness separating the oil and water bulk phases.
6
The R-ratio is the ratio of molecular interaction energies on the
oil to the water side of the C-layer. For an R-ratio equal to
unity, the surfactant has equal affinity toward the oil and water
regions. This occurs at optimum conditions, where the
surfactant solubilizes oil and water equally. However, the use
of R-ratio is not practical, as interaction energies at the
molecular level are not known.
Several attempts have been made to predict optimum
conditions, which are of special interest to chemical enhanced
oil recovery applications. Salager and coauthors presented an
empirical equation valid at optimum conditions for oil-water-
brine systems in the presence of an anionic surfactant.
7
That
relationship was extended to include the effect of pressure,
Received: July 18, 2016
Published: August 9, 2016
Article
pubs.acs.org/Langmuir
© 2016 American Chemical Society 8969 DOI: 10.1021/acs.langmuir.6b02666
Langmuir 2016, 32, 8969-8979