Journal of Building Engineering 29 (2020) 101144
Available online 24 December 2019
2352-7102/© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Hybrid short-term forecasting of the electric demand of supply fans using
machine learning
Jason Runge , Radu Zmeureanu
*
, Mathieu Le Cam
Centre for Net-Zero Energy Buildings Studies, Department of Building, Civil and Environmental Engineering, Concordia University, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Multi-step-ahead forecasting
Artifcial neural network
Ensemble
Supply air fow rate
Hybrid grey-box
Electric demand
Sliding window
ABSTRACT
This paper presents the development and application of multi-step-ahead short-term forecasting models targeting
supply fans installed in an institutional building. The models applied in this work consist of an artifcial neural
network (ANN) applied in order to forecast the future supply air fow rate of the fans (black-box approach), and a
physical model coupled with the ANN applied in order to forecast the future electric demand of the supply fans
(hybrid grey-box approach). The forecasting models use measurement data obtained at 15-min intervals in order
to forecast the target variables over the next 6 h. The architecture of the ANN was found through an automated
search in the training data set. The paper compares the results of selected ANN models with those from other
machine learning techniques (support vector regression and ensemble methods) along with a simple forecasting
approach. The results of this study show a better forecasting performance when compared with the results from
other publications: the CV(RMSE) is 1.8–3.4% for the air fow rate, and 4.8–7.3% for the electric demand for all
new models. The results demonstrate that automating the hyperparameter search of the ANN architecture can
help alleviate the diffculty of manual parameter setting and achieve a high performing model.
1. Introduction
Our cities and populations are growing, concurrently, so is our en-
ergy demand. In Canada, approximately 19% of the total secondary
energy usage is consumed by electricity [1]. From that, the residential
and commercial/institutional sectors consume approximately 53% [1,
2]. Within the United States, the residential and commercial/institu-
tional sectors consume approximately 40% of the total primary energy
consumption [3] and 71% of the electricity usage [4]. Therefore,
increasing the energy effciency in buildings is of great importance to
global sustainability.
Forecasting the energy consumption in buildings has received a lot of
development in recent years as it underpins many techniques for
improving building energy performance through: fault detection and
diagnosis, demand side management, energy optimization, and demand
response. To date, the main focus for forecasting has been on the short-
term load profles of buildings as this has close ties to the day-to-day
operations. Specifcally, the majority of building energy forecasting
papers have focused on forecasting an overall energy load (heating,
cooling, and electricity) within a building using hourly data for their
models.
Despite the focus of forecasting models being applied to the overall
energy loads within a building, the heating, ventilation, and air condi-
tioning (HVAC) equipment remains an area of interest as it contributes
to a large portion of the electric demand within a building (e.g., 19–67%
for a commercial building [5]).
The HVAC system is a complex, nonlinear system involving
numerous variables, many of them correlated. This makes the devel-
opment of a forecasting model targeting the electric demand of the
HVAC equipment a challenging endeavor, especially as this can be
highly occupant driven. This paper is a contribution to the development
of short-term forecasting models for the electric demand of HVAC
equipment.
2. Literature review
2.1. Overview of forecasting models
Merriam-Webster [6] defnes the action to forecast as “to calculate or
predict (some future event or condition) usually as a result of study and
analysis of available and pertinent data”. Within this paper, to forecast is
defned as the estimation of future values of a variable, given its current
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: radu.zmeureanu@concordia.ca (R. Zmeureanu).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Building Engineering
journal homepage: http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jobe
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jobe.2019.101144
Received 19 July 2019; Received in revised form 14 December 2019; Accepted 22 December 2019