40 International Journal of E-Politics, 3(3), 40-60, July-September 2012
Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited. Copyright © 2012, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Keywords: CapabilityApproach, Conviviality, Defense, Fear, Freedoms, Information and Communication
Technologies (ICTs), Politics
INTRODUCTION
The English political philosopher Thomas
Hobbes asserted that people are ruled not by
reason but by passions like appetite for power
and the aversion for pain and death. These pas-
sions fuel a violent effort to attain security which
eventually instils fear in others (Hobbes, 1968).
Using Hobbes’ (1968) thinking we suggest that
the conviviality of ICTs makes authoritarian
regimes paranoid about who controls the ICT
sector and the power they are capable of wield-
ing with both ICTs and the proceeds from the
lucrative business. According to Illich (1973)
convivial tools are tools that give the person
who uses them the greatest ability to enrich their
environment with the fruit of their own vision.
We argue that it is this fear (of the conviviality
of ICT) and appetite (for power and money)
that breeds repressive legislature that stifles
free use of ICTs.
Over the last two decades, adoption of ICTs
has been show-cased as a new development
mantra for the global south (Avgerou & Madon,
2003; Unwin, 2009). Inhibitors of ICT in devel-
oping countries have been associated with the
digital divide issues like lack of infrastructure
and ICT skills. Studies have mainly addressed
The Effect of Politics on ICT4D:
A Case of Econet Wireless’s Struggle
for a License in Zimbabwe
Sam Takavarasha Jr., University of Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe
John Makumbe, University of Zimbabwe, Zimbabwe
ABSTRACT
Zimbabwe is the best contemporary example of how politics can affect economic development. Equally as
signifcant, and yet under studied, is the effect of politics on Information and Communication Technologies
for development (ICT4D). In this case study of government of Zimbabwe’s fve year battle to prevent Econet
Wireless from operating a mobile phone network, the authors present the fear for the conviviality of ICTs as
a reason why dictatorial states often restrict free use of ICTs and how this can inhibit its role in fostering de-
velopment. Using a combination of aspects of Thomas Hobbes’political theory and Sen’s capability approach
the authors show how passions like fear for the power of ICTs in private hands and the appetite for proceeds
from the telecoms sector fuelled a fve year legal battle that was eventually won by Econet. A framework for
assessing the motives behind restrictive political action and the concomitant erosion of political freedoms
which inhibits free ICT use and investment in the sector is also presented.
DOI: 10.4018/jep.2012070103