LETTERS
Hoffmann’s syndrome in
hypothyroid myopathy.
ReportofacaseinanAfrican
El Hassane Sidibe
1
, Abdoulaye Ndoye Diop
1
,
Alé Thiam
2
, Pape Massar Diagne
2
, Anna Sarr
1
,
Meissa Toure
3
, Moctar Diop
4
1
Service de médecine interne, centre Marc-Sankalé, clinique
médicale II, BP 5062, Fann, Dakar, Senegal ;
2
clinique
neurologique, CHU Fann, Dakar, Senegal ;
3
laboratoire de
biochimie, Faculté de Médecine, UCAD, Senegal ;
4
institut Joliot-
Curie, institut du cancer, Dakar, Senegal
Africa / hypertrophic myopathy / myxedema / primary
hypothyroidism
Several forms of hypothyroid myopathy have been
reported, including hypertrophic myopathy with clini-
cal evidence of myotonia but no myotonic pattern on
the electromyogram, hypertrophic myopathy without
myotonia, myotonia without muscle hypertrophy, and
muscle wasting. The last three forms are classically
believed to be extremely uncommon, even today,
although one-third of patients with hypothyroidism
report muscle symptoms and 25% have abnormalities
in muscle contraction-relaxation. Debré-Kocher-
Semelaigne syndrome in children (muscle weakness,
slow movements, and marked muscle hypertrophy)
and Hoffmann’s syndrome in adults (muscular promi-
nence, weakness, and stiffness) are two special patterns
of hypothyroid myopathy. Muscle hypertrophy is an
extremely rare finding in clinical practice; its cause is
unknown, and it is thought to be worsened by low
temperatures. Upon histologic examination, the muscle
fibers seem edematous, the normal striations are absent,
and mucin deposits are visible between the fibers [1].
We report the case of an adult with Hoffmann’s
syndrome documented by enzyme assays, electromyo-
gram tracings, and histologic studies. We discuss cur-
rent knowledge on hypothyroid myopathy, particularly
with muscle hypertrophy.
CASE REPORT
This 31-year-old mother of two stopped the hormone
replacement therapy she had been prescribed for pri-
mary hypothyroidism. She was admitted for gradual
onset of severe weakness in all four limbs. The first
symptom had been myalgia of the girdle muscles. Two
weeks prior to her admission, she had started experienc-
ing pain in the anterior chest and exertional dyspnea.
At admission, she was unable to get out of bed. Her
movements were infrequent and slow. Swelling of the
face and loss of the lateral part of the eyebrows were
noted. Her blood pressure was 100/60 mm Hg, her
heart rate 100 beats/minute, her body temperature
37° C, her body weight 78 kg, and her height 167 cm.
A striking finding was marked hypertrophy of the limb
muscles predominating at the roots of the limbs. Muscle
relaxation was abnormally slow. Myxedema was found
upon percussion. The idiomuscular reflex and deep
tendon reflexes were abolished. Sensation was normal.
The heart sounds were muffled. A diffuse goiter was
felt, with no other local abnormalities.
A roentgenogram of the chest showed enlargement of
the cardiac shadow (cardiothoracic index, 0.6). Low-
wave amplitude and concordant repolarization disor-
ders were noted on the electrocardiogram.
Echocardiography demonstrated a free-flowing effu-
sion with no heart chamber dilatation or Doppler
abnormalities. Serum hemoglobin was 11 g/L, was
98 mg/L, and serum phosphate was 26 mg/L. Serum
creatine kinase was elevated to 4533 IU/L (normal,
25–195) and serum lactic dehydrogenase to 1280 IU/L
(normal, 200–400). Radioimmunoassays showed
decreases in serum T4 (to 46.97 nmol/L; normal,
64–141) and total T3 (to 0.36 nmol/L; normal,
1.2–3.4). Serum TSH was elevated to 25.5 μUI/mL
(N < 3.5).
The electromyogram demonstrated a myogenic pat-
tern at the girdles and evidence of distal axonal neur-
opathy. This combination was suggestive of
hypothyroidism. A muscle biopsy showed perivascular
atrophy without inflammation; substantial neuron loss
was seen, as well as degeneration of the small and
medium-sized axons and evidence upon teasing of
marked fibrosis of the normal fibers. The histologic
diagnosis was moderate nonspecific neuromyopathy.
Joint Bone Spine 2001 ; 68 : 84-6
© 2001 Éditions scientifiques et médicales Elsevier SAS. All rights reserved