Identification of Viscoelastic Functions for Hot-Mix Asphalt
Mixtures Using a Modified Harmony Search Algorithm
Sungho Mun
1
and Sangyum Lee
2
Abstract: This study proposes a modified harmony search (MHS) algorithm for determining the time-domain viscoelastic function of hot-
mix asphalt (HMA) concrete materials. This MHS technique, employing a global optimization technique as well as a Wiechert model for the
relaxation function, substantially enhances accuracy and consistency in the determination of viscoelastic functions of several HMA mixtures.
In addition, this study shows how to determine a time-domain Prony series representation from the complex modulus in the frequency domain
using the MHS algorithm. This can be efficiently used for numerical analysis with techniques such as the finite-element method. The results
from lab frequency sweep tests of unmodified and lime-modified HMA at various asphalt contents were consistent with the functions
obtained from the MHS algorithm. DOI: 10.1061/(ASCE)CP.1943-5487.0000078. © 2011 American Society of Civil Engineers.
CE Database subject headings: Viscoelasticity; Asphalts; Mixtures; Algorithms.
Author keywords: Harmony search; Frequency sweep test; Wiechert model; Prony series representation.
Introduction
Many techniques exist for predicting the viscoelastic material func-
tion in the time domain from a linear viscoelastic (LVE) response
function in the frequency domain (Emri and Tschoegl 1995; Park
and Schapery 1999; Park and Kim 2001; Mun et al. 2007). The
methods for the conversion from frequency to time domain and
for the interconversion between LVE functions have been investi-
gated based on the theory of linear differential and integral
equations.
Prony series representation is widely used for time-domain LVE
functions because of its ability to describe a wide range of visco-
elastic responses and the computational efficiency and stability
associated with its exponential basis functions (Taylor et al.
1970; Kaliske and Rothert 1997). Several techniques have been
developed to fit the Prony series representation to the LVE response
function. For example, Schapery (1961) used a collocation method,
and Emri and Tschoegl (1995) developed a recursive computer
algorithm that generates line spectra from experimental response
functions. Ramkumar et al. (1997) used a regularization method
based on quadratic programming to minimize the oscillations of
the experimental data, while Park and Schapery (1999) and Schapery
and Park (1999) developed novel methods of interconversion
based on numerical and approximate analytical approaches. Park
and Kim (2001) solved the problem of negative Prony series
coefficients or oscillations by fitting the Prony series with a
power-law presmoothing function, and Mun et al. (2007) proposed
a two-step approach to overcome the problems of oscillations in the
fitted curve and negative Prony series coefficients. It is widely
accepted that the number of coefficients in the Prony series repre-
sentation has to correspond to the number of decades in analysis
(Park and Schapery 1999; Schapery and Park 1999; Park and
Kim 2001). The other techniques of expressing relaxation spectra
in time domain are available (e.g., Lee and Knauss 2000; Sorvari
and Malinen 2006; Sorvari and Malinen 2007; Mun and Zi 2010).
This study proposes a modified harmony search (MHS) algo-
rithm to determine a time-domain Prony series representation of
hot-mix asphalt (HMA) concrete, resulting in nonnegative Prony
coefficients, which are spring constants in a series representation
model. This algorithm is based on a time-varying coefficient
(TVC) (Naka et al. 2003; Ratnaweera et al. 2004; Tripathi et al.
2007) and the conceptualization of a behavioral phenomenon in
the improvisation process of searching for a better state of musical
harmony (Geem et al. 2001; Mun and Geem 2009a, b). This
method reduces the number of Prony coefficients as compared with
other methods (Park and Kim 2001; Chehab 2002; Mun et al.
2007), and thus reduces the numerical computation costs of the
convolution integral that represents the LVE constitutive relation-
ship between stress and strain.
The remainder of the paper is organized into the following sec-
tions: the details of the linear viscoelastic model and material
parameters; the MHS algorithm along with some constraints; the
determination of Prony series coefficients; and concluding remarks
that summarize the paper.
Linear Viscoelastic Model
A frequency sweep test was performed to obtain the LVE material
properties of various HMA mixtures. Viscoelastic material proper-
ties, such as complex and dynamic modulus, can be determined
from this test.
Frequency Sweep Test
The frequency sweep test consists of a haversine loading applied to
a cylindrical specimen of an HMA mixture. The load amplitude is
1
Assistant Professor, School of Civil Engineering, Seoul National Univ.
of Science and Technology, 138 Gongneung-gil, Nowon-gu, Seoul, 139-
743, South Korea; formerly, Senior Researcher, Expressway and Transpor-
tation Research Institute, Korea Expressway Corporation, 50-5, Sancheok-
ri, Dongtan-myeon, Hwaseong-si, Gyeonggi-do, 445-812, South Korea
(corresponding author). E-mail: smundyna@gmail.com
2
Director, Road Management Division, Seoul Metropolitan Govern-
ment, Deoksugung-gil 15, Jung-gu, Seoul, 100-110, South Korea. E-mail:
slee11@seoul.go.kr
Note. This manuscript was submitted on November 27, 2009; approved
on May 24, 2010; published online on June 7, 2010. Discussion period
open until August 1, 2011; separate discussions must be submitted for
individual papers. This paper is part of the Journal of Computing in Civil
Engineering, Vol. 25, No. 2, March 1, 2011. ©ASCE, ISSN 0887-3801/
2011/2-139–148/$25.00.
JOURNAL OF COMPUTING IN CIVIL ENGINEERING © ASCE / MARCH/APRIL 2011 / 139