Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jasrep
Determining the suitability of gold bulking villages articulated to the
Lepanto gold district of Northwestern Luzon with the aid of WorldView2
satellite imagery
Michael Armand P. Canilao
Department of Anthropology, University of Illinois at Chicago, United States
Archaeological Studies Program, University of the Philippines Diliman, Philippines
ABSTRACT
This paper presents a suitability model of bulking villages in the Lepanto gold district using the weighted overlay
technique. An as an alternative to more environment-deterministic modelling in GIS, an attempt is made to use a
hybrid of both environmental variables with social variables. The resulting raster model was then overlain on
image enhanced WorldView2 scenes to remote sense high probability sites for bulking villages. Two known sites
were also tested if their locations conformed to the gold bulking model. Danac site was more conducive to
accommodate transshipment of bulkier loads while the Apaya site was more conducive to spotting ship arrivals
on the coast. The variation is arguably connected to the latitude of agency of the upland gold miners vis a vis the
lowland coastal polities.
1. Introduction
The paper is a second case study of the gold evanescent market
(Allegre, 1998: 148) encounters in Northwestern Luzon (NWL) Island
between the 10th to the early 20th c (Fig. 1). The first case study in-
volved the Antamok/Balatok-Tonglo-Aringay gold trading trails in the
present day Province of Benguet (see Canilao, 2017). The trade network
circulated products such as porcelain, silk, cotton, beeswax, gems,
beads, and more importantly precious minerals such as gold, silver and
tin (Junker, 1999: 222). The results of the case study present some
interesting questions about the nature of gold trade in terms of access
and control. But what is really interesting would be the divergences that
we see between computer generated least cost path data and histori-
cally recorded data in ancient accounts, maps, sketches and oral tra-
ditions. It is possible that such divergences give us a purview into the
local and regional social, economic, political landscape at the time.
Noting that gold is the central commodity being moved from point to
point, it is interesting to reconstruct the geopolitical landscape in the
past in order to see how small scale indigenous miners negotiated their
position in the local NWL market in the background of an expansive
Indian Ocean- South China Sea (IO-SCS) trade system.
In this case study, we begin with the question, how can we model
locations of gold trade bulking villages? There are several GIS ap-
proaches to predictive modelling of archaeological sites. Most ap-
proaches; however, have been criticized for being too reliant on en-
vironmental variables (see Wescott, 2001: 66, Lock and Harris, 2001:
44). Kvamme (2001: 23) is asking the community of GIS predictive
modelling archaeologists to tap on more social variables into their
analysis. Thus it is the attempt of this case study to integrate social
variables in tandem with environmental variables.
There are certain characteristics that a bulking village location must
possess. In terms of slope and land class it can be suitable for dry cul-
tivation at the minimum and wet cultivation at the maximum. Laurence
Wilson for instance observed that the upland people pursued a spec-
trum of subsistence strategies wherein on one hand they are in-
defatigable prospectors; but at the same time, they also hunt, fish,
harvest root crops (i.e., taro, camote), harvest rice in the paddies,
gather wood, raise livestock, among other activities (1932: 4). In be-
tween these activities they can investigate outcrops, slides, and cuts and
assay gold bearing veins (ibid). This spectrum of activities may be re-
lated to the putative “risk-reducing social strategies” (Rockman, 2003:
17) that people use to mitigate extraction of patchy resources.
Given this flexibility in agricultural methods it can be argued then
that slope degree is less of a determining factor in deciding where to
establish the bulking village of the Igorots in NWL. Historical data also
seem to support this argument when Quirante in his 1624 expedition
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jasrep.2017.06.039
Received 7 May 2017; Received in revised form 18 June 2017; Accepted 25 June 2017
E-mail address: mcanil2@uic.edu.
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 14 (2017) 620–637
2352-409X/ © 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
MARK