XXX-X-XXXX-XXXX-X/XX/$XX.00 ©20XX IEEE
Piezoelectric Force Sensor-based Measurement
System for Recoil Force Analysis
Ibrahim Sami Ilter
Mechatronics Engineering Department
Istanbul Gedik University
İstanbul, Turkey
isilter@outlook.com
Savaş Dilibal
Mechatronics Engineering Department
Istanbul Gedik University
İstanbul, Turkey
savas.dilibal@gedik.edu.tr
Harun Zengin
Industrial Engineering Department
Marmara University
İstanbul, Turkey
harunzengin@marun.edu.tr
Abstract—In this study, a piezoelectric force sensor-based
experimental recoil force analysis was performed via examining
the formation and effects of recoil forces after overviewing the
related experimental studies in the literature. The experimental
measurement and the analysis of the recoil forces of the selected
shotguns were carried out systematically after selecting the
accurate piezoelectric force sensor for the dynamic performance
of the recoil mechanism. The experimental setup required for
the measurement was built via integrating the selected
piezoelectric force sensor, signal conditioner, data acquisation
card with a software developed in Visual Basic .NET software
language. A developed measuring apparatus was designed to
measure the dynamic recoil forces of different shotgun system.
The selected piezoelectric force sensor can detect the recoil
forces with 36 kHz measurement capacity. All of the data were
recorded in real-time. The recorded data were examined, and
analyzed comparatively. The collected measurement results are
evaluated according to the recoil mechanisms, barrel lengths,
weights, and other effective parameters that may affect the
recoil forces in the experimental analysis. It was observed that
the shotgun that spreads the recoil force over time reduces the
peak point and has minimum total recoil energy among the gas
cycle, inertia and hybrid shotguns with 71cm barrel length and
included 12GA caliber.
Keywords—recoil force, experimental analysis, piezoelectric
force sensor
I. INTRODUCTION
Humans have used shotguns as one of the significant
defense tools for centuries. These instruments are also used in
shooting competitions in Olympic games. The advances in
shotgun recoil absorber mechanisms dramatically accelerated
with the support of detailed engineering background via
nonlinear modeling and experimental analysis [1].
Recoil force is the result of the momentum change with
the acceleration of the projectile and the pressurized gases
generated via combustion [2]. The exit of the gunpowder gas
from the barrel accelerates the movement of the shotgun with
applied force. When the recoil force cannot be controlled well
it can cause some injuries during the shots with shotguns and
other light weapons. Additionally, the recoil force can affect
the user's performance. The sequence of shotguns’ recoil force
occurred inside of the barrel can be analyzed via measuring
the applied force of a shotgun using high-speed sensor
systems. The accurate measurement of the recoil force can
unveil the dynamic performance of the system.
Many studies have been made on the dynamic
performance of recoil mechanism considering total recoil time
and recoil length [3-4]. Different recoil absorber systems were
used to reduce the maximum recoil force transmitted to the
recoil segment via compansator system. The spring segments,
fluid viscous dampers, muzzle brakes are the most common
passive recoil compensator mechanisms. In addition to the
passive recoil absorber, the magnetorheological (MR) [5] and
electrorheological (ER) [6] smart fluid damper systems have
been proposed in the literature as novel effective recoil
absorber mechanisms with dynamic yield strength. Recent
studies have considered the use of shape memory alloys
(SMA) as alternative damping elements [7] for many
potential applications in industry with their unique
superelastic response and shape memory characteristics. They
can work in different smart systems in two-way [8] or
antagonistic manner [9-12].
According to the Newton's third law, the felt recoil force
by the shooter from the shotgun is equal and opposite to the
force the shooter applies on the shotgun. Thus, the magnitude
of the recoil force and the magnitude of the applied force by
the shooter with the time histories are directly related to many
parameters, such as shooting style and shotgun operation
mechanism [1]. The sensor selection process is an important
phase to detect the applied dynamic peak forces in the
experimental studies. The selected sensor should offer high
resolution for measuring the recoil force in a real-time
experimental system.
In terms of the operation mechanism, the shotguns have
mainly gas-operated, inertia, and hybrid operating systems.
These are the most preferred semi-auto shotgun operating
systems by hunters, shooters, and manufacturers. In this study,
the measured recoil forces of three different semi-automatic
shotguns with different operating systems were compared.
Semi-automatic shotguns can be fired via throwing the
empty cartridge after each trigger pull, loading a new cartridge
into the chamber from the magazine, and pulling the trigger
again. Shotguns with different operating systems provide the
required energy to dispose of the empty cartridge after firing
and to replace it with a new cartridge with different methods.
Gas-operated semi-automatic shotguns perform these
operations using the pressurized gas in the barrel during firing
process. As shown in Fig. 1, the gas-operated semi-automatic
shotguns allow them to cycle by transferring some of the
gunpowder gas behind the bullet onto the bolt through the gas
port.