Potential Removal and Release of Nanomaterials from Wastewater
Treatment Plants
Mehlika A. Kiser
1*
, Paul Westerhoff
1
, Troy M. Benn
1
, Yifei Wang
1
, Hodon Ryu
2
, Kiril
Hristovski
1*
1
Arizona State University (ASU), P.O. Box 875306, Tempe, AZ 85287-5306
2
USEPA-NRMRL (MS-387), 26 W. Martin Luther King Dr., Cincinnati, OH 45268-0001
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. Email: ayla@asu.edu.
ABSTRACT
We studied the occurrence, characterization, and removal of nano- and larger-sized titanium (Ti)
in a full-scale wastewater treatment plant. Raw sewage contained 100 – 3,000 μg/L Ti, while
tertiary effluent Ti concentrations ranged from about 10 to 100 μg/L. The Ti that was removed
across the treatment train accumulated in plant solids. Finished plant biosolids, tertiary effluent,
and commercial toothpaste were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy, and various forms
of Ti solids were observed, including aggregates containing nanoscale primary particles of
titanium oxides. To support field work, laboratory batch sorption experiments were conducted
with various types of nanoparticles as sorbates and wastewater biomass as sorbent. Upon
exposure to 400 mg/L total suspended solids of wastewater biomass, 97% of silver nanoparticles
88% of fullerenes, 39% of functionalized nanosilver, 23% of nanoscale titanium dioxide, and
only 13% of fullerol nanoparticles were removed.
KEYWORDS: Nanomaterials, release, wastewater, sorption, fate and transport
INTRODUCTION
As the number of consumer products containing engineered nanomaterials increases, the release
of nanomaterials into sewage will inevitably increase as well (Benn and Westerhoff, 2008; Kiser
et al., 2009). Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) collect society’s wastes, including
engineered nanomaterials, and distribute them into the environment through treated effluent,
biosolids, and/or aerosols. Thus, quantification and characterization of the release of engineered
nanomaterials from WWTPs will be an important contribution to understanding nanomaterial
environmental fate and assessing exposure. Recent nanomaterial exposure modeling predicts
that nanoscale titanium dioxide (TiO
2
) is found in WWTP effluent at concentrations several
times higher (0.7 – 16 μg/L) than the no-effect concentration (1 μg/L) (Nowack and Bucheli,
2007). Furthermore, TiO
2
has been used in consumer products for decades – mostly in bulk
form, though increasingly in nanoscale form. Titanium (Ti) may thus serve as an indicator of the
fate of nanomaterials passing through a WWTP. We report current Ti concentrations in a full-
scale municipal WWTP and characterize nanoscale Ti in biosolids and tertiary effluent. To
support field work, degrees of sorption of nanoscale TiO
2
, non-functionalized and functionalized
nanosilver (Ag), and non-functionalized and functionalized fullerenes (C
60
) to wastewater
WEFTEC 2010
Copyright ©2010 Water Environment Federation. All Rights Reserved.
899