* Corresponding author:
Cecilia Matasci
email: cecilia.matasci@empa.ch
Detritus / Volume 14 - 2021 / pages 25-31
https://doi.org/10.31025/2611-4135/2021.14057
© 2020 Cisa Publisher. Open access article under CC BY-NC-ND license
HOW TO INCREASE CIRCULARITY IN THE SWISS ECONOMY?
Cecilia Matasci *, Marcel Gauch and Heinz Böni
Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, Technology and Society Laboratory - Lerchenfeldstrasse 5,
CH-9014 St. Gallen, Switzerland
Article Info:
Received:
3 July 2020
Revised:
15 October 2020
Accepted:
25 November 2020
Available online:
26 February 2021
Keywords:
Circular economy
Life cycle assessment
Material fow analysis
Climate change
Domestic material consumption
WEEE
ABSTRACT
Environmental threats are triggered by the overconsumption of raw materials. It is
therefore necessary to move towards a society that both reduces extraction and
keeps the majority of the extracted raw materials in the socio-economic system.
Circular economy is a key strategy to reach these goals. To implement it effectively,
it is necessary to understand and monitor material fows and to defne hotspots, i.e.
materials that need to be tackled with the highest priority. This paper is aimed at
determining how to increase circularity in the Swiss economy by means of a Material
Flow Analysis coupled with a simplifed Life Cycle Assessment. After having char-
acterized material fows, we analyzed two types of hotspots: i) Raw materials con-
sumed and/or disposed at high level, and ii) Raw materials whose extraction and pro-
duction generates high environmental impacts. The Material Flow Analysis shows
that each year 119 Mt of raw materials enter the Swiss economy. Therefrom, 15 Mt
are derived from recycled waste inside the country; 67 Mt leave the system yearly; 27
Mt towards disposal. Out of the disposed materials, 56% are recycled and re-enter
the socio-economic system as secondary materials. Looking at hotspots; concrete,
asphalt, gravel and sand are among materials that are consumed and disposed at
high level. Yet, looking at greenhouse gas emissions generated during extraction and
production, metals - including the ones in electrical and electronic equipment - as
well as textiles are among the categories that carry the biggest burden on the envi-
ronment per unit of material.
1. INTRODUCTION
The publication of the Planetary Boundaries concept
in 2009 (Rockström et al., 2009) and its update in 2015
(Steffen et al., 2015) showed that global-scale alteration
of biogeochemical fows, biosphere integrity, land-system
change and climate change are the major environmental
threats that humanity is facing nowadays. These threats
are a consequence of human overconsumption of natural
resources (O’Neill et al. 2018). It is therefore essential to
understand factors that drive raw material consumption
and the fows of materials that this generates. This allows
tackling hotspots and developing pathways to reach a 'safe
operating space for humanity' (Heijungs et al., 2014; O’Neill
et al. 2018), for example by reducing extraction and keep-
ing the majority of the extracted raw materials in the so-
cio-economic system.
Broken down the Swiss economy, we see a need for
quantifying fows of materials and energy with their related
environmental impacts. Studies exist assessing the mate-
rial input and the environmental consequences (Jungbluth
et al., 2011; Frischknecht et al., 2014; Frischknecht et al.,
2018), or the environmental consequences of resource and
energy recovery in waste management systems (Haupt,
2018). However, to our knowledge there are no studies
focusing on the material inputs and outputs of the entire
economic system, including considerations about the recy-
cling effciencies and losses (incineration, landflling).
This paper aims at determining how to increase circu-
larity of raw materials in the Swiss economy. It does so
by: i) Characterizing mass fows, ii) Assessing the environ-
mental impacts generated by these fows, and iii) Defning
which raw materials are hotspots, i.e. are either consumed
and/or disposed at high level or their extraction and pro-
duction generates high environmental impacts. The result
of this research is meant to support the Swiss government
in taking decisions for moving towards more circularity in
material management.
2. MATERIALS AND METHODS
2.1 Material fows of Swiss economy
To address the circularity of the Swiss economy and to
answer the research question of this paper, we carried out
a static Material Flow Analysis (MFA) covering the mate-
rial metabolism within the Swiss economy and coupled it