Agronomy Journal • Volume 111, Issue 2 • 2019 1
M
ost of oilseed production worldwide is dominated
by soybean ( Glycine max L. [Merr.]), rapeseed
(Brassica napus L.), sunfower (Helianthus annuus
L.) and cotton ( Gossypium hirsutum L.). Tese major crops are
sensitive to climate and soil conditions and some require large
amounts of fertilizers to produce acceptable yields. Relying on
few crops also contributes to less diversifcation of agricultural
land use. Te use of more sustainable oil crops that require less
inputs, ofers environmental and agronomic benefts to ensure
product stability in terms of climate change with respect to bio-
diversity and efcient use of agricultural lands but also may have
lower oil yield potential (Elfadl et al., 2009). Recently, research
on new oilseed species such as Crambe abyssinica (Zanetti et al.,
2013), niger ( Guizotia abyssinica Cass.) (Solomon and Zewdu,
2008), cuphea ( Cuphea viscosissima Jacq. × C. lanceolata W.T.
Aiton, PSR23) (Berti et al., 2008) calendula ( Calendula ofci-
nalis L.) (Johnson and Gesch, 2013) and camelina (Mohammed
et al., 2017) as potential sources of oil crops has increased.
Blessed thistle is an annual plant belonging to the Asteraceae
family and is widely spread from Asia Minor to Caucasus, includ-
ing Iran, Afghanistan, Syria and Mediterranean Europe, and
appears promising as an oil crop for cultivation in arid and warm
climate regions (Horn et al., 2015). It is tolerant to poor nutrient
soils and dryland areas, as it is typically found in marginal lands
that are not suited for other crops. Approximately 3 to 6 Mg ha
–1
of dried aerial biomass and 300 to 600 kg ha
–1
seed yield can
be expected in sunny and warm locations that have calcareous
loamy sand soils with sufcient water supply (Horn et al., 2015).
However, higher seed yields of 1.3 Mg ha
–1
(Von Regel, 1940)
and 2 Mg ha
–1
were recorded for blessed thistle grown under
medium quality soils, that is, diluvial and loess sites (soil value
index around 50) in Germany (Horn et al., 2015). Blessed thistle
seeds contain 240 to 280 g kg
–1
oil, which are primarily unsatu-
rated linoleic and oleic fatty acids like those of sunfower and saf-
fower ( Carthamus tinctorius L.) oils (Roth and Kormann, 2000).
According to Horn et al. (2015), blessed thistle can be cultivated
as an oil crop in low input farming production systems, due to its
desirable characteristics of oil and grain yield. Tus, blessed thistle
has a potential to be a promising industrial crop in low yielding
soils and low input conditions. In addition, the oilcake obtained
Seed and Biomass Yield Responses of Blessed Thistle
to Nitrogen and Density
M. Ghiasy-Oskoee, M. AghaAlikhani,* A. Mokhtassi-Bidgoli, F. Sefdkon, and M. Ayyari,
Published in Agron. J. 111:1–11 (2019)
doi:10.2134/agronj2018.05.0323
Copyright © 2019 by the American Society of Agronomy
5585 Guilford Road, Madison, WI 53711 USA
All rights reserved
ABSTRACT
Developing alternative oilseed crops with acceptable seed yield
and biomass production in low-yielding environments could
be a part of sustainable agriculture management strategies.
Field experiments were conducted in a semiarid region of Iran
in 2013 and 2014 to determine the efects of N fertilizer rates
and plant densities on growth, seed yield and quality of blessed
thistle ( Cnicus benedictus L.) under low yielding conditions.
Randomized complete-block design with factorial arrangement
of treatments was used in three replicates. Treatments consisted
of four N rates (0, 50, 100, and 150 kg N ha
–1
) combined with
fve plant densities (5, 10, 15, 20, and 25 plants m
–2
). According
to quadratic functions, the maximum seed yield (913 kg ha
–1
)
was achieved with 122 kg N ha
–1
and 16 plants m
–2
. Although
the seed oil content decreased with increasing N rates, increased
seed yield partially compensated for the reduction in oil con-
tent. Higher seed protein was obtained from low plant densities
(5–10 plants m
–2
) and high N rates (100–150 kg N ha
–1
). Nitro-
gen harvest index (NHI) decreased by 30 to 40% as a result of
increased plant density across all N rates. Plant density and N
did not afect seed fatty acid profles, even though N rate by year
interaction afected the profle. Linoleic acid was the predomi-
nant fatty acid comprising 62.5 to 66.2% of the total fatty acids.
Te study demonstrates that blessed thistle could be a promis-
ing oil crop for cultivation in low yielding soils, although breed-
ing work is needed to enhance its prospects as a viable oil crop.
M. Ghiasy-Oskoee, M. AghaAlikhani, and A. Mokhtassi-Bidgoli,
Dep. of Agronomy, Faculty of Agriculture, Tarbiat Modares Univ.,
PO Box 14115-336, Tehran, Iran; F. Sefdkon, Research Institute of
Forests and Rangelands, PO Box 13185-116, Tehran, Iran; M. Ayyari,
Dep. of Horticultural Science, Tarbiat Modares Univ., PO Box
14115-336, Tehran, Iran. Received 14 May 2018. Accepted 12 Sept.
2018. *Corresponding author (maghaalikhani@modares.ac.ir).
Abbreviation: NHI, nitrogen harvest index.
Core Ideas
• Tis is the frst report of blessed thistle response to nitrogen and plant
density.
• Optimizing nitrogen and density improved quality and quantity of
blessed thistle seed.
• Under low yielding conditions, the actual yield of blessed thistle is ac-
ceptable.
• Blessed thistle is rich in polyunsaturated fatty acids such as linoleic acid.
CRop ECology And phySIology
Published online January 4, 2019