J Youth Adolescence (2018) 47:445–459
DOI 10.1007/s10964-017-0722-4
EMPIRICAL RESEARCH
The Protective Role of Parental Media Monitoring Style from
Early to Late Adolescence
Laura M. Padilla-Walker
1
●
Sarah M. Coyne
1
●
Savannah L. Kroff
1
●
Madison K. Memmott-Elison
1
Received: 26 May 2017 / Accepted: 14 July 2017 / Published online: 8 August 2017
© Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2017
Abstract The goal of the current study was to examine
the protective role that maternal media monitoring might
have for adolescents. This was done by considering whether
styles of media monitoring either directly reduced media
use, or whether they buffered the associations between
aggressive media use and adolescents’ prosocial behavior,
aggression, and delinquency. Participants were 681 ado-
lescents from two cities in the United States (51% female;
73% white), and their mothers, who provided data at two
different time points, 2 years apart (when adolescents were
roughly ages 13 and 15). Mixture modeling results revealed
that mothers used four different styles of media monitoring
made up of combinations of active and restrictive mon-
itoring as well as forms of co-use. Styles that included
active monitoring and connective co-use (i.e., engaging in
media with the intent to connect with children) were directly
associated with less media use, and moderated links
between adolescents’ media use and behavioral outcomes
concurrently but not longitudinally. The discussion was
focused on the strength of considering multiple strategies of
media monitoring together, and how this approach can
inform future research in the area of parental media
monitoring.
Keywords Parental media monitoring
●
Parental
mediation
●
Media use
●
Parenting styles
Introduction
It is no surprise that the amount of time children and teens
spend consuming media continues to rise given the sheer
number of media outlets available to children today (e.g.,
video games, social media platforms, smartphones, apps,
on-demand television and movies, personal computers and
tablets; Rideout 2016). Though children are exposed to a
considerable amount of media, more than half of media
exposure takes place at home (Strasburger et al. 2013),
providing an opportunity for parents to become involved in
monitoring their children’s media use. Because of the
transitionary nature of adolescence and the increase in
media use for children in this age range (Rideout 2016),
parental involvement has the potential to be particularly
influential during the teen years. Research to date has been
conducted on different strategies of parental media mon-
itoring (e.g., restrictive, active) largely in isolation of others,
while traditional parenting scholars suggest that the coa-
lescence of different parenting strategies create an overall
emotional climate, or parenting style (Darling and Steinberg
1993). In similar fashion, a variety of specific strategies
parents use to monitor media may combine to create an
overall media climate that then may be related to children’s
behavior or acts as a moderator of the impact media has on
child outcomes. Thus, the purpose of this paper was to take
a person-centered approach to parental media monitoring to
examine how groups of parents might use specific strategies
in combination to create climates or “styles” of media
monitoring. Person-centered approaches assume that there
* Laura M. Padilla-Walker
laura_walker@byu.edu
Sarah M. Coyne
smcoyne@byu.edu
Savannah L. Kroff
savi.keenan@gmail.com
Madison K. Memmott-Elison
madimemmott@gmail.com
1
Brigham Young University, Provo, UT 84602, USA