The Effects of Using the STAD Method in Teaching the Short Story,
Flipping Fantastic on Form One Students
Subadrah Madhawa Nair
1
and Chee Peck Kim
2
1
Universiti Utara Malaysia (subadrah@uum.edu.my)
2
Khir Johari Secondary School, Kedah (peckimchee@yahoo.com)
Abstract. Since the year 2000 literature components have been introduced in the English language syllabus
of the secondary schools in Malaysia. However until today not all teachers are aware of the possible best
ways of teaching literature components effectively. This study discusses the Student Teams Achievements
Divisions (STAD) method and the effect of using the method in the teaching of a short story on Form One
students. The researchers used a quasi experimental design to investigate the effects of using the STAD
method on the achievement of students in comprehending the short story, and their interest in learning the
short story. The experimental group was taught using the STAD method and the control group was taught
using the conventional method. Independent sample T-test was used to analyze the data obtained from the
pre-test, post-test and the questionnaires. The findings indicate that the utilization of the STAD method
significantly enhanced students’ achievement in answering questions related to setting, plot, characterization,
theme and moral values compared with the control group (using the conventional method). The interest of the
experimental group in reading short story was also significantly enhanced.
Keywords: The STAD method, reading comprehension, short stories, students’ interest.
1. Introduction
The literature component was introduced into the English language syllabus in the year 2000. Through
the introduction of this component, students “would find the base for an appreciation of literature in English
with its concerns with humanity, values, beliefs and customs as well as its great tradition and heights of
imagination and creativity” ( Ministry of Education, Malaysia , 2003, p.5). The second round of the literature
component implementation started in the year 2010, “….the main objectives of this component are to
promote the love for books and encourage the reading habits among pupils between the ages of 13 and 17 in
secondary schools” ( Ministry of Education Malaysia, 2010). Based on several studies conducted by
researchers, the teaching and learning of literature is effective and beneficial to students only if students are
given the opportunity to participate actively using authentic materials in literature. Chacko (2007) stressed
that there is a need to research the learner-centred approaches in the learning of literature in Malaysian ESL
classes because the learners in Malaysian schools come from different socio-economic and cultural
backgrounds.
1.1. Problem statement
The literature component has now been part of the English language curriculum in Malaysian secondary
schools for more than thirteen years. However, the true scenarios in most rural schools show that the students
are still vague about what they have studied in literature component. They do not know how to appreciate the
culture in the poem or the short story. They are also weak in interpreting the social, political, literary and
historical perspectives of a specific text. For most of them literature is just an ordinary reading text.
Therefore, the majority of students are not interested in reading. Hence to them literature is burdening.
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: subadrah@uum.edu.my.
156
2014 4th International Conference on Education, Research and Innovation
IPEDR vol.81 (2014) © (2014) IACSIT Press, Singapore
DOI: 10.7763/IPEDR.2014.V81.24