CSIRO PUBLISHING
www.publish.csiro.au/journals/ajsr Australian Journal of Soil Research, 2005, 43, 623–628
Rice growth and post-rice mungbean in relation to two puddling
intensities under glasshouse conditions
G. Kirchhof
A,B
and H. B. So
A
A
The University of Queensland, School of Land and Food Sciences, Brisbane, Qld 4072, Australia.
B
Corresponding author. Email: g.kirchhof1@uq.edu.au
Abstract. The effect of soil puddling on growth of lowland rice (Oryza sativa) and post-rice mungbean (Vigna
radiata) was investigated using mini rice beds under controlled glasshouse conditions. Each mini rice bed was
approximately 1 m
3
in size. Three different soil types were used: a well-drained, permeable loam; a hardsetting,
structurally unstable silty loam; and a medium clay. Rice yields were reduced by low puddling compared with
high puddling intensity on the loam but not affected on the heavier textured soils (silty loam and clay). Yield of
mungbean was reduced on highly puddle, structurally unstable soil, indicating that puddling should be reduced on
structurally unstable soils. Under glasshouse condition where crop establishment was not a limiting factor and plant
available water in 0.65 m of soil was 100 mm, mungbean yields of >1 t/ha were achieved. However, under conditions
where subsoil water reserves were depleted for the production of vegetative biomass during initial optimal growing
condition, grain yield remained well below 1 t/ha.
Additional keywords: rice, mungbean, tillage, soil puddling, soil structure, dryland.
Introduction
The total global area of rainfed lowland rice (Oryza sativa)
was 40.5 million ha in 1992 (IRRI 1993), which is 18%
of the global rice supply. Most of these areas are located
in Asia: 36% in south Asia, 43% in south-east Asia, and
27% in east Asia (IRRI 1993). In these areas rice is grown
during the wet season on bunded fields. Soil preparation
for rice traditionally requires soil puddling. It assists in
weed control, facilitates transplanting, and reduces water loss
through a decrease in water percolation rates, and therefore
flooded conditions can be maintained for at least part of the
rice cropping season. Irrigation is limited and generally not
available during and after the rice crop. Rice fields are often
left fallow due to the lack of water for an upland crop in the
dry season following rice. However, soil water contents are
generally high after rice harvest following several months
of inundated conditions. Usage of soil water stored in the
profile should be sufficient to grow a moderate upland crop,
provided crop establishment is adequate and roots can access
the subsoil water store. Potential crops in rice rotations
are pulses, e.g. soybean (Glycine max), mungbean (Vigna
radiata), or groundnut (Arachis hypogaea), wheat (Triticum
aestivum), and maize (Zea mays). Maize is generally grown
at the end of the dry season and harvested before rice
planting. In The Philippines, mungbean contributed 35% of
the net return in a rice–mungbean–fallow system, although
mungbean yields were as low as 0.33t/ha following a rice
crop of 4.1 t/ha (IRRI 1994). Under experimental conditions,
mungbean yields of >2 t/ha were achieved without irrigation
(IRRI 1985). Yields were mainly affected by rooting depth.
Yield increases for mungbean of 100 kg/ha were observed for
additional exploitable soil depth ranging from 0.07 to 0.13 m
(IRRI 1985, 1986, 1988).
Poor soil physical conditions are the major limiting factor
for successful upland cropping following rice. Soil puddling
degrades soil structure and leads to reduced infiltration rates.
Although macropores as elongated transmission pores are
decreased, the total porosity of puddled soils is generally
increased due to an increase in small pores (Pagliai and
Painuli 1988; Sharma and Bhagat 1993). The strength of
puddled soil increases rapidly during drying (Cook et al.
1995). This is important for seed germination and crop
establishment. If seeds are sown too late after rice harvest, soil
strength may be too high, resulting in poor crop establishment
and shallow root systems with subsequent early onset of
water stress leading to poor yields or crop losses. If seeds
are sown too early after rice harvest, anaerobic conditions
may reduce crop establishment and decrease yield potential
(IRRI 1987).
A potential strategy to minimise soil structural
degradation in rice-based cropping systems is a reduction in
soil puddling (So and Woodhead 1987). Although beneficial
effects from reduced puddling may increase post-rice
legume yields, it may also increase water use, increase
© CSIRO 2005 10.1071/SR04067 0004-9573/05/050623