279
Journal of Sport Rehabilitation, 2013, 22, 279-287
© 2013 Human Kinetics, Inc.
www.JSR-Journal.com
ORIGINAL RESEARCH REPORT
Gaudreault and Gauthier are with the School of Rehabilitation,
University of Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, Canada. Fuentes and
Mezghani are with the Imagery and Orthopedics Research
Laboratory, University of Montreal Hospital Center, Montreal,
Canada. Turcot is with the Willy Taillard Kinesiology Labora-
tory, Geneva University Hospitals, Geneva, Switzerland.
Relationship Between Knee Walking Kinematics
and Muscle Flexibility in Runners
Nathaly Gaudreault, Alex Fuentes, Neila Mezghani, Virginie O. Gauthier, and Katia Turcot
Context: Decreased fexibility in muscles and joints of lower extremities is commonly observed in runners.
Understanding the effect of decreased fexibility on knee walking kinematics in runners is important because,
over time, altered gait patterns can make runners vulnerable to overuse injuries or degenerative pathologies.
Objectives: To compare hamstring and iliotibial-band (ITB) fexibility and knee kinematics in runners and
nonrunners. Design: A descriptive, comparative laboratory study. Setting: Hamstring and ITB fexibility
were measured with the active knee-extension test and the modifed Ober test, respectively, in both groups of
participants. Three-dimensional (3D) walking kinematic data were then recorded at the knee using a motion-
tracking system. Participants: 18 runners and 16 nonrunners. Main Outcome Measures: Knee-extension angle
(hamstring fexibility) and hip-adduction angle (ITB fexibility). Knee kinematic parameters of interest included
knee angle at initial contact, peak knee angles, and knee-angle range in all planes of movement. Results: The
runners had a signifcantly less fexible ITB than the nonrunners (hip adduction [–] and adduction [+] angles,
3.1° ± 5.6° vs –6.4° ± 4.5°; P < .001). The runners demonstrated a greater mean tibial external-rotation angle
at initial contact (7.3° ± 5.8° vs 2.0° ± 4.0°; P = .01) and a smaller mean peak tibial internal-rotation angle
(–1.6° ± 3.0° vs –4.2° ± 3.2°; P = .04) than the nonrunners. Conclusion: This study provides new insight into
the relationship between muscle fexibility and 3D knee kinematics in runners. This supports the premise that
there is an association between muscle fexibility and transverse-plane knee kinematics in this population.
Keywords: gait analysis, sports rehabilitation, iliotibial band
For many individuals, long-distance running is the
sport of choice. This is supported by a search on Run-
ning USA and popular North American marathon Web
sites (eg, Boston, Ottawa, and New York), which reveals
a signifcant increase in the number of participants in
these events over the past several years. For example,
since 2000, the number of half-marathon fnishers in the
United States has more than tripled (from 482,000 to
1,610,000), an increase of 234%.
1
The health benefts and
accessibility of this sport certainly contribute to its grow-
ing popularity. Nevertheless, running has been frequently
associated with musculoskeletal injuries,
2–4
the majority
being related to the knee
4,5
and overuse.
4,6
Decreased flexibility of the tensor fascia latae/
iliotibial band (ITB) complex and hamstrings has been
commonly reported in runners.
7,8
Anatomical and sci-
entifc evidence support the potential role of decreased
fexibility of these soft tissues in the pathomechanics of
overuse knee injuries.
7,9
The ITB takes its origin in the
fascial components of the tensor fascia latae, the gluteus
maximus, and the gluteus medius muscles.
10,11
Distally,
ITB fbers connect to the linea aspera via the lateral
intermuscular septum, terminating just proximal to the
lateral condyle of the femur.
10,11
ITB fbers also attach
to the patella and to the lateral tibial tubercle, known as
Gerdy’s tubercle. Due to its tibial attachment, ITB tight-
ness can interfere with internal/external tibial rotation and
abduction/adduction movement of the knee during walk-
ing. Merican and Amis
12
studied the effect of increasing
ITB tension on knee kinematics. They concluded that as
the ITB tension increased, the tibia was more externally
rotated. However, Merican and Amis’ data were col-
lected on cadavers and during an open-kinetic-chain
movement, and their results cannot be generalized to an
in vivo gait-analysis context. Studying the relationship
between decreased ITB fexibility and tibial rotation is
clinically relevant because there is evidence that runners
with ITB syndrome present changes in tibial rotation
compared with symptom-free runners.
13
As regards the
hamstrings, they pass across the hip and knee. As the
hip goes into fexion during the terminal swing phase of
gait, decreased fexibility of the hamstrings can reduce
the range of knee-extension movement observed during
that period. It can therefore be hypothesized that a greater
knee-fexion angle at initial contact could be observed.
The contact force between the patella and the femur starts