RESEARCH ARTICLE
Voltage stability analysis based on optimal placement of
multiple DG types using hybrid optimization technique
Ali Selim
1
| Salah Kamel
2
| Francisco Jurado
1
1
Department of Electrical Engineering,
University of Jaén, Jaén, Spain
2
Department of Electrical Engineering,
Faculty of Engineering, Aswan University,
Aswan, Egypt
Correspondence
Francisco Jurado, Department of
Electrical Engineering, University of Jaén,
23700 EPS Linares, Jaén, Spain.
Email: fjurado@ujaen.es
Funding information
NSFC (China)-ASRT (Egypt) Joint
Research Fund, Grant/Award Number:
51861145406
Peer Review
The peer review history for this article is
available at https://publons.com/publon/
10.1002/2050-7038.12551.
Abstract
This article proposes a hybrid analytical and metaheuristic optimization tech-
nique for optimal allocation of multiple types of distributed generator (DG) in
radial distribution networks. DG integration aims to minimize the total power
losses and enhance the voltage stability of the distribution system. The proposed
technique is formulated using the analytical technique which utilizes the exact
loss formula to calculate the initial DG size at a certain bus. However, the ana-
lytical technique may not be proper to allocate multiple DGs types due to the
mass of calculations, hence, a metaheuristic optimization technique named Tree
Growth Algorithm (TGA) is combined with the analytical technique to find the
final solution of optimal DG locations and sizes. The hybridization between the
analytical and metaheuristic optimization techniques combines the advantages
of both techniques and eliminates the disadvantages. The proposed hybrid Ana-
lytical TGA (ATGA) is validated using the stranded radial distribution feeders,
IEEE 33-bus and 69-bus and practical 94-bus Portuguese system. A comprehen-
sive comparison between the proposed technique and other competitive optimi-
zation techniques is carried out to prove its effectiveness. The result shows that
the proposed hybrid ATGA is efficient to allocate the multiple DGs types with
minimum power loss and a high convergence rate.
KEYWORDS
DG location, hybrid optimization, power loss minimization, tree growth algorithm, voltage
stability
List of Symbols and Abbreviations: P
loss
, total power losses; P
i
, Q
i
, active and reactive power at bus i; N
bus
, the total bus number; α
ik
, β
ik
, branch
coefficients; V, voltage magnitude; θ, phase angle; Z
busik
, bus matrix; w
1
,w
2
, weighting factor; PD
i
, QD
i
, the demand active and reactive power at bus i;
PG
i
, QG
i
, generated active and reactive power; n, numbers for DG type I; PG
a1
, PG
a2
, PG
an
, generated active power at a
1
, a
2
, …a
n
; m, numbers for DG
type II; QG
b1
, QG
b2
, QG
m
, generated reactive power at b
1
, b
2
, …b
m
; C
ai
, coefficient matrix for DG type I; E
bi
, coefficient matrix for DG type II; G
1
,G
2
,
G
3
,G
4
, the main group of Tree Growth Algorithm; k, iteration number; k
max
, maximum number of iterations; T
k
GB
, global best tree at iteration k; T
k
i
,
tree position at iteration k; r, uniform distributed between [0,1]; d
i
, distance between trees; y, linear combination between trees; x
1
,x
2
, two minimal
distance solutions; μ, uniformly distributed factor [0,1]; α
i
, adjacent best tree angle [0, 1]; DGs, distributed generators; IA, improved analytical; ELF,
exhaustive load flow; LSF, loss sensitivity factor; PSI, power stability index; VSI, voltage stability index; GA, genetic algorithm; PSO, particle swarm
optimization; BSOA, backtracking search optimization algorithm; BFOA, bacterial foraging optimization algorithm; SKHA, stud krill herd algorithm;
BAT, Bat algorithm; MVGWO, modified variant grey wolf optimizer; CSA, Cuckoo search algorithm; TGA, Tree Growth Algorithm; ATGA, analytical
tree growth algorithm; LR, loss reduction.
*Corresponding author, Tel.: +34 953 648 518; Fax: +34 953 648 586.
E-mail addresses: fjurado@ujaen.es (F. Jurado), ali.selim@aswu.edu.eg (A. Selim), skamel@aswu.edu.eg (S. Kamel).
Received: 3 July 2019 Revised: 4 May 2020 Accepted: 18 June 2020
DOI: 10.1002/2050-7038.12551
Int Trans Electr Energ Syst. 2020;e12551. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/etep © 2020 John Wiley & Sons Ltd 1 of 20
https://doi.org/10.1002/2050-7038.12551