IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON MAGNETICS, VOL. 51, NO. 3, MARCH 2015 8101004
End-Region Leakage Fluxes and Losses Analysis of Cage
Induction Motors Using 3-D Finite-Element Method
Jalal Cheaytani
1,2
, Abdelkader Benabou
1
, Abdelkader Tounzi
1
, Maxime Dessoude
2
,
Loïc Chevallier
1
, and Thomas Henneron
1
1
Lille Laboratory of Electrical Engineering and Power Electronics, University of Lille1, Villeneuve d’Ascq 59655, France
2
Département THEMIS, EDF Research and Development, Clamart Cedex 92141, France
The stray load losses (SLLs) in electrical machines represent a nonnegligible contribution of the total losses and a key point
for an accurate evaluation of the energy efficiency of considered device. In this paper, one aspect of these SLLs, the end-region
leakage fluxes and losses, is investigated and considered for the case of a high-power cage induction motor. The study is performed
at locked rotor, no-load, and rated load conditions using a 3-D finite-element modeling approach. The influence of the leakage flux
on the end-region conductive parts of the motor is analyzed together with the eddy current loss calculation. Finally, the SLLs are
calculated and compared with the experimental measurements based on the IEEE standard 112-method B test.
Index Terms—Eddy currents, end-region leakage fluxes, finite-element (FE) method, induction motor, stray load losses (SLLs).
I. I NTRODUCTION
A
LARGE percentage of the electrical demands in the
industry is linked to the use of induction electrical
machines. Thus, in the context of energy saving, efficiency
classes have been defined for these machines. Therefore, it has
become essential to estimate their losses and efficiency right
from the design step to fulfill the standard requirements.
In induction machines, the losses can be classified into
mechanical, primary copper, secondary copper, iron, and stray
load losses (SLLs). Many studies have been focused on how
to estimate the end-region leakage fluxes and losses of turbo
generator [1] or induction machines [2]. Nevertheless, none of
these works was interested in the influence of the end-region
losses on the SLLs.
As defined in [3], SLLs represent the difference, at load,
between on the one hand, the total losses in the electrical
machine and, on the other hand, the sum of friction and
windage, stator I
2
R, rotor I
2
R, and core losses. These SLL
can be nonnegligible and are considered as a key point for an
accurate evaluation of the machine efficiency. Consequently,
several efforts based on experimental approaches, analytical,
or 2-D finite-element (FE) models have been made to identify
and evaluate the SLL components [4], but without accounting
for the end-region losses.
This paper improves the SLL studies by considering the
end-region leakage fluxes effects using a 3-D FE model,
in the case of a high-power nonskewed cage induction motor.
The study is performed at no-load, locked rotor, and rated load
conditions.
In the first part, the mathematical model iron and SLLs
models are described along with the studied machine. The sec-
ond part is devoted to the calculation of the end-region losses.
Simulation results are given in the last part showing no-load
iron losses and SLLs compared with experimental results.
Manuscript received May 21, 2014; revised September 9, 2014; accepted
October 21, 2014. Date of current version April 22, 2015. Corresponding
author: J. Cheaytani (e-mail: jalal.cheaytani@ed.univ-lille1.fr).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TMAG.2014.2365355
II. MODELING APPROACH
A. Mathematical Model
In this paper, the numerical study is achieved using a
3-D FE method based on the electrical A-ϕ formulation to
account for the eddy currents in the squirrel cage bars
curl
1
μ
curlA
+ σ
∂ A
∂ t
+ gradϕ
= J (1)
where A is the magnetic vector potential, such as B = curl(A),
ϕ is the electric scalar potential, μ is the magnetic
permeability, σ is the electric conductivity, and J is the
source current density. The permeability μ is described by
the nonlinear and single-valued magnetic behavior law of the
iron core proposed in [5].
B. Iron Loss Model
To determine the iron losses, an approach based on Bertotti’s
iron loss decomposition into three contributions [6] is used in
this paper
W
i
= W
h
+ W
cl.
+ W
exc
(2)
where W
i
, W
h
, W
cl.
, and W
exc
are, respectively, the total iron,
quasi-static hysteresis, and classic eddy current and excess
losses. The iron losses are calculated through an analytical
postprocessing procedure, implemented in a time-stepping
FE calculation code. The time evolution of the magnetic field
is stored, once the steady state is reached, for every element
of the mesh where the iron losses are computed according to
the following equations:
W
h
= k
h
f
ΔB
2
α
(3)
W
cl
= k
cl
1
T
T
0
dB(t )
dt
2
dt (4)
W
exc
= k
exc
1
T
T
0
dB(t )
dt
1.5
dt (5)
where f is the frequency, B is the peak-to-peak magnetic
flux density, T is the period of the waveform, and k
h
, α,
0018-9464 © 2015 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.