Flexural and Shear Behavior of Rubberized High
Strength Reinforced Concrete Beams
Strengthened with CFRP
Ahmed S. Eisa, Ahmed Gab Allah, Ragab Shaker Mahmoud
Department of Structural Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Zagazig University, Zagazig, Egypt
Email:ahmedeisa@zu.edu.eg, eng_ahmedgaballah2010@yahoo.com, Ragabshaker@yahoo.com
Ahmed Ibrahim
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Idaho, Moscow, ID, 83843, USA
Email:aibrahim@uidaho.edu
Abstract—This study presents an experimental investigation
of the flexural and shear behavior of strengthened high
strength concrete (HSC) beams made with rubberized
concrete. CFRP has been used in strengthening of all beams
in shear and bending. The concrete mixtures have included
a 15% of sand replaced with crumbed rubber with a size of
2 mm. Ten (10) simple span concrete beams have been
prepared and tested to promote both flexure and shear
failures. The tested beams were divided into two groups,
where each group was divided into five beams. The first
group was tested to fail in flexure and the second group in
shear. Beams with crumbed rubber showed very good
flexural and shear strength and all the strengthening
techniques used were very effective in both flexure and
shear. It was found that the most effective flexural and
shear failure loads were increased by 51% and 64%,
respectively. Overall, the results showed the feasibility of
using rubberized beams in structural applications.
Index Terms—crumb rubber, compressive strength,
strengthening, flexural Strength, CFRP, ductility
I. INTRODUCTION
In the last 40 years, the compressive strength of cast-
in-place concrete has been quite doubled, from 35 to 85
MPa. Strengths as high as 140 MPa are often achieved
within the laboratory and on rare occasions in the field.
Ultra-high strength concrete has been accomplished using
reactive powder concrete with no coarse aggregates
included. These advances have been made possible by
two major developments: the introduction of high range
water-reducing admixtures (HRWRA) and the utilization
of nano-silica fume. Chemical admixtures allow the
generation of workable concrete with very low water-to-
cement ratios, and silica fume could produce cement
paste with very low porosity.
Nowadays, high strength concrete (HSC) is being used
more and more frequently which offers smaller sections
and thus result in more useable floor space compared to
normal strength concrete (NSC). In addition, HSC has
been used in joints between precast columns and beams
for full development strength and for improving
durability and service life. In addition, early strength
development of HSC could accelerate construction
schedules significantly. For example, a 105 MPa of HSC
could gain a one-day compressive strength of 35 MPa
compared to NSC which gains it in a month. Also, HSC
exhibits excellent workability and ability to self-desiccate,
thus reducing or eliminating moisture problems.
Various research have investigated the replacement of
fine and coarse aggregates by crumb rubber to produce
rubberized concrete. Neil et al. [1], investigated the
strength characteristics of rubberized concrete and
examined the relationship between the size, percentage,
and shape of rubber aggregate size and the strength
measured. Rubberized concrete was found to possess
acceptable workability, and a smaller unit weight
compared to plain concrete. Overall, rubberized concrete
showed greater ductility than normal concrete specimens.
Toutanji et al. [2], investigated the effect of the
replacement of mineral coarse aggregates by shredded
rubber tire chips. All specimens were moist cured for 28
days at a temperature of 29 “C (850 F) and at a relative
humidity in excess of 95%. A total of 50 cylindrical
specimens were made (25 for compression and 25 for
flexure). The study concluded that the failure of
specimens containing rubber tire chips exhibited a ductile
mode of failure compared to the control specimens. The
incorporation of these rubber tire chips in concrete
exhibited a reduction in compressive and flexural
strengths. the reduction in compressive strength was
approximately twice the reduction of the flexural strength.
Similar conclusions were obtained by Zheng et al. [3],
Raghvan et al. [4], and Khatib et al. [5].
The rehabilitation of infrastructures is not new, and
various projects have been carried out around the world
over the past two decades. Historically, steel has been the
ordinary material used to strengthen concrete bridges and
buildings. Bonded steel plates or stirrups have been
applied externally to successfully repair concrete girders
98
International Journal of Structural and Civil Engineering Research Vol. 10, No. 3, August 2021
doi: 10.18178/ijscer.10.3.98-105
© 2021 Int. J. Struct. Civ. Eng. Res
Manuscript received December 1, 2020; revised March 21, 2021;
accepted May 8, 2021.