Journal Name
COMMUNICATION
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 20xx J. Name ., 2013, 00 , 1-3 | 1
Please do not adjust margins
Please do not adjust margins
Received 00th January 20xx,
Accepted 00th January 20xx
DOI: 10.1039/x0xx00000x
www.rsc.org/
Solid Form and Solubility
Christopher A. Hunter*
a
and Rafel Prohens
b
Factors that determine the solubility of polymorphs and cocrystals
are analysed using experimental data to show that the change in
the solubility of a compound produced by the formation of a
multicomponent crystal can be estimated in a straightforward
manner, if the solubilities of the pure compound and the coformer
are known.
Bioavailability
1
is one of the most important issues in the
development of a new drug, and water solubility
2
is one of the
most important parameters that has an impact on the oral
bioavailability. Since the fraction of new drug candidates with
poor water solubility is very high (≈ 70%),
3
different strategies
are being pursued to develop more soluble drugs.
4
One option
is solid form modification. Amorphous materials and
metastable polymorphs have relatively high solubilities, but
these materials have associated risks, because they can
transform into the most stable and less soluble polymorph
during formulation or in storage.
5
The use of multicomponent
crystals is a promising approach to improving the solubility of
an active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) as a stable solid
form.
6
However, the number of potential coformers available
to modify solubility is very high, so there is a need for methods
to predict which compounds are likely to form cocrystals and
what the impact on solubility is likely to be.
7
In this paper, we
use experimental data to investigate the relationship between
solubility and the free energy differences between different
solid forms.
The free energy differences between different solid phases
(polymorphs or cocrystals) can be related to solubility products
in a specific solvent through the thermodynamic cycles
depicted in Figure 1.
Fig. 1. Relationship between solubility products in a specific solvent, KS, and the free
energy difference between two different solid forms, ∆G°, at a given temperature: (a)
two polymorphs of compound A and (b) the m:n cocrystal of A and B.
Thus in a polymorphic system the free energy difference
between two polymorphs can be directly related to the
difference in their solubilities (Figure 1a, Equation 1).
∆
°
= −
!
+ n
!
!
Eq. 1
Similarly in a two component cocrystal the free energy
difference between the cocrystal and the pure solid phases of
the components can be related to the difference between the
solubility of the cocrystal and the solubilities of the pure
components (Figure 1b, Equation 2).
Δ
°
= −
!
!!!
!
A −
!
!!!
!
B +
!
!!!
!
(A
!
!
)
Eq. 2
where m and n define the cocrystal stoichiometry, ∆G° is the
free energy change per total number of moles of the two
components in the cocrystal (i.e. m+n), K
S
(A
m
B
n
) is the
solubility product of the cocrystal in a specific solvent, and
K
S
(A) and K
S
(B) are the solubility products of the pure
components, A and B, in the same solvent.