Comparison of Hurdle Treatment and Thermal Treatment on
Ascorbic Acid and Total Phenolic Content of Winter Melon Puree
Stored at Different Temperature
Noriham Abdullah, Wan Saidatul Syida Wan Kamarudin
, Zainal Samicho, Nurain Aziman and
Khairusy Syakirah Zulkifli
Faculty of Applied Sciences, Universiti Teknologi MARA, 40450 Selangor, Malaysia
Abstract. Winter Melon (WM) is an important fruit in China, India, Philippines and elsewhere in Asia and
due to its perishable characteristic it is a necessity to process it into a puree form. Hence in this study, WM
fruit was processed into puree and hurdle technology (HT) treatment was compared with traditional thermal
treatment (TT) to see the effect on Ascorbic acid (AAC) and Total Phenolic (TPC) content stored at different
temperatures for 6 months of storage. HT WMP was adjusted to pH 3 using citric acid while for TT WMP
was prepared by heating at 84.5⁰C for 94 seconds. Both treated WMP were stored at 25⁰C, 5⁰C and -20⁰C
and were analyzed at 1 months storage intervals till 6 months. AAC test was conducted using 2, 6-
dichlorophenol-indophenol titration method and TPC was determine by using Folin-Ciocalteu. A gradual
decrease in AAC and TPC were observed during storage for both treatments. These changes were more
pronounced at 25⁰C storage for both treatments (P < 0.05), however, TT shows high reduction of AAC and
TPC (P < 0.05) at 0 months throughout 6 months of storage as compared to HT. Overall, WMP for HT stored
at 5⁰C and -20⁰C shows lowest reduction for AAC and TPC for the last 6 months of storage. By processing
WM into puree, it will be more convenient to use especially by the food manufacturer. In contrast to
traditional TT for common fruits puree preparation, HT could imply new opportunities for WMP in
developing value-added product with reasonable shelf life.
Keywords: Hurdle technology, Thermal treatment, Winter melon puree, Total phenolic content, Ascorbic
acid content
1. Introduction
Winter melon (WM) or its scientific name Benincasa hispida belongs to a family of Curcubitaceae and
its origin is from South East Asia and also can be found in area outside Asia [1]. Some scientific studies
carried out reveal the potential of WM as anti-inflammatory [2], anti-diarrheal [3], anti-ulcer [4], antioxidant
[5] and antimicrobial agent [5]. In Malaysia, WM is popular fruit among Chinese and Indian communities
and it has potential for the food industry. It is prized for its pleasant smell and juicy flesh. However, it
softens rapidly during ripening and becomes mushy and difficult to consume in fresh. Moreover due to these
reasons, it will be rejected by the consumers if these fruits are bruised. Therefore, there is a need to process
WM into puree form. Winter melon puree (WMP) needs a considerable treatment before canning and before
storage. Therefore in this study, two treatments were proposed which are thermal treatment (TT) and hurdle
technology (HT). Thermal treatment (TT) is a combination of the temp-time profile to ensure microbial
destruction and to stabilise the WMP by removing microorganisms and enzyme inactivation that could
produce fermentation or spoilage. Study by Sanchez et al. (1990)[6]; Umme et al. (2001)[7] and Bartolome
et al. (1995)[8] reported that fruit puree processed below 93⁰C, canned and stored frozen showed no much
Wan Saidatul Syida Wan Kamarudin. Tel: +60132677647
Email Address: thermopolis_mia@yahoo.com
2012 International Conference on Environment, Chemistry and Biology
IPCBEE vol.49 (2012) © (2012) IACSIT Press, Singapore
DOI: 10.7763/IPCBEE. 2012. V49. 8
36