This article has been accepted for inclusion in a future issue of this journal. Content is final as presented, with the exception of pagination.
IEEE MICROWAVE AND WIRELESS COMPONENTS LETTERS 1
Novel Improved Sensitivity Planar Microwave
Probe for Adulteration Detection
in Edible Oils
Nilesh Kumar Tiwari , Surya Prakash Singh , and M. Jaleel Akhtar , Senior Member, IEEE
Abstract—Novel design of the complementary split ring res-
onator (CSRR) loaded planar microwave probe with improved
sensitivity is proposed for liquid adulteration detection. As com-
pared to the conventional planar resonant sensors, the proposed
single-port structure is quite advantageous for detecting adulter-
ation in edible fluids since it can directly be immersed inside the
liquid specimen. The flared microstrip line of the proposed probe
facilitates the etching of two CSRRs on the top side at the electric
field maxima resulting into the compact design with improved
sensitivity. The parameters of the probe are optimized using the
CST-MWS, and its prototype is fabricated, which possesses the
ability to easily distinguish two materials having close dielectrics
values. Finally, the proposed probe is successfully employed for
adulteration testing of various edible oils where the presence of
common adulterants such as mineral oil inside high-quality olive
oil and mustard oils can be clearly detected.
Index Terms— Adulteration detection, complementary split
ring resonator (CSRR), flared microstrip line, planar microwave
probe, sensitivity.
I. I NTRODUCTION
M
ICROWAVE resonant sensors have been used for var-
ious industrial and biomedical applications in the past
decades due to their higher measurement accuracy [1]–[7].
During the past few years, the compact low-cost resonant
sensors have been mainly realized using the metamaterial
inspired structures [3]–[7]. The metamaterial inspired split ring
resonator/complementary split ring resonator (SRR/CSRR)
possesses various advantages such as low profile, compact
size, and their ease of integration with the other existing planar
structures thus making them popular in recent times. However,
most of the SRR and CSRR-based sensors available in the
literature are of nonsubmersible types which seem inappropri-
ate for testing liquids. It is to be noted that the conventional
coaxial probe sensor has quite often been used for testing
liquids accurately by immersing the probe inside the test
liquid [8]. Recently, the SRR-based-planar structure has been
proposed as the submersible sensor to characterize solid and
liquid samples [7]. However, the measured sensitivity (shift in
the resonant frequency/unit change in dielectric constant) of
the submersible sensor in [7] is relatively low (3.04%), due
to the lower dielectric sensitivity of the SRR [5].
Manuscript received September 14, 2018; revised November 2, 2018;
accepted November 29, 2018. This work was supported by DST India under
Grant DST/TSG/ME/2015/97. (Corresponding author: Nilesh Kumar Tiwari.)
The authors are with IIT Kanpur, Kanpur 208016, India (e-mail:
nileshkt@iitk.ac.in).
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available
online at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/LMWC.2018.2886062
The sensor in [7] is also not compact because of its two-
port design topology and lower operating frequency. The lower
sensitivity of the sensor [7] makes it a somewhat unsuitable
for the adulteration detection of edible oils, where both parent
oil and mineral oil having dielectric constant values close to
each other. In the present scenario, the detection of mineral oil
mixed with edible oils is a serious challenge in various parts
of the world, as it directly affects human health by causing
serious diseases such as liver damage, cancer, paralysis, and
cardiac arrest [9].
In this letter, a novel CSRR-based-open-ended microstrip
structure with improved sensitivity is proposed to implement
a compact submersible sensor. As compared to the earlier
reported conventional CSRR loaded microstrip-based sensors,
the proposed sensor is different since, in the proposed struc-
ture, the CSRR is directly etched on the top side of the open
ended flared microstrip line. This fact makes the proposed
sensor quite compact along with some advantages as compared
to the conventional CSRR-based sensors. The first advantage
is that the single port of the proposed structure makes it
convenient for detecting adulteration in edible oils since it
can directly be immersed inside them. Second, the proposed
sensor shows improved measured sensitivity of ∼9% because
of the fact that the two CSRRs are etched on the main line
laterally near the open end of the structure where the maximum
electric field region is observed. To show the applicability of
the proposed sensor, the adulteration of various edible oils with
mineral oil is mainly tested as it can be considered as the most
common adulterant in various edible oils [9]. The minimum
deducible frequency shift corresponding to 10% adulteration
of mineral oil in the edible oils is found to be ∼14 MHz using
the designed probe sensor.
II. DESIGN OF THE PROBE SENSOR
The proposed single-port flared microstrip line loaded with
optimized CSRR resonators shown in Fig. 1 is presented as
a submersible probe sensor. As the flared microstrip structure
is kept open at the other end, it behaves like an open-ended
line thus facilitating the formation of a standing wave pattern
along the line as depicted in Fig. 2(a). To obtain the better
interaction with the electric field, the CSRRs are loaded near
the flared end. For observing the actual electric field around
the sensing element at the resonant frequency, its plot is shown
in Fig. 2(b), where the strong electric field localization in the
electrically small sensing region can be observed. Based on
the electric field distribution, it can be ascertained that the
1531-1309 © 2018 IEEE. Personal use is permitted, but republication/redistribution requires IEEE permission.
See http://www.ieee.org/publications_standards/publications/rights/index.html for more information.