IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON PLASMA SCIENCE, VOL. 37, NO. 12, DECEMBER 2009 2303
Nitric Oxide Formation in a Premixed Flame With
High-Level Plasma Energy Coupling
Xing Rao, Igor B. Matveev, and Tonghun Lee
Abstract—This paper presents quantitative planar laser-
induced fluorescence (PLIF) imaging of nitric oxide (NO) in a
transient-arc direct-current plasmatron igniter using premixed
air/fuel mixtures. Quantitative measurements of NO are reported
as a function of gas flow rate (20–50 standard cubic feet per
hour), plasma power (100–900 mA, 150–750 W), and equivalence
ratio (0.7–1.3). Images were corrected for temperature effects by
using 2-D temperature field measurements obtained with infrared
thermometry and calibrated by a more accurate multiline fitting
technique. The signals were then quantified using an NO addition
method and spectroscopic laser-induced fluorescence modeling
of NO. NO PLIF images and single-point NO concentrations
are presented for both plasma-discharge-only and methane/air
plasma-enhanced combustion cases. NO formation occurs pre-
dominantly through N
2
(v)+ O → NO + N for the plasma-
discharge-only case without combustion. The NO concentration
for the plasma-enhanced combustion case (500–3500 ppm) was
an order of magnitude less than the plasma-discharge-only case
(8000–15 000 ppm) due to the reduction of plasma reactions by the
methane. Experiments show the linear decay of NO from equiv-
alence ratio 0.8–1.2 under the same flow condition and discharge
current.
Index Terms—Nitric oxide (NO), plasma torch, plasma-assisted
combustion.
I. I NTRODUCTION
D
EVELOPMENT and investigation of nonequilibrium
plasma discharge for enhancing combustion is receiving
increased attention due to its potential application to a variety
of problems such as finding a more efficient method of fossil
fuel combustion, conversion of low-grade fuels into higher
grade fuels, and reduction of pollution through ultralean burn
combustion [1], [2]. Advantages of combining plasma dis-
charge with thermal oxidation include faster and more intense
chemical energy conversion, increased stability in the lean
flammability limit, reduction of pollution by altering oxidation
byproducts, improved fuel efficiency through more complete
combustion, more reliable and rapid ignition, and stable fuel
oxidation across a broader range of pressures and temperatures
[3]–[8].
Manuscript received February 11, 2009; revised July 28, 2009 and
September 30, 2009. Current version published December 11, 2009. This work
was supported by Michigan State University through the Intramural Research
Grants Program’s New Faculty Award.
X. Rao and T. Lee are with the Department of Mechanical Engineering,
Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI 48823 USA (e-mail: tonghun@
msu.edu).
I. B. Matveev is with Applied Plasma Technologies, McLean, VA 22101
USA.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPS.2009.2034007
Addition of electromagnetic energy can alter the reaction
mechanisms by the following: 1) decomposition of the fuel
gas from larger to smaller hydrocarbon molecules and radicals
via the electron gas with temperature T
e
; 2) radiation-induced
electron excitation; 3) increased flame temperature by ohmic
heating, which increases the rates of reaction and transport;
and 4) increased ion/electrons on key radical initiation and
propagation reactions. Recently, Kim et al. [9], [10] have
shown that fuel reforming into syngas plays a dominant role
in stabilization of flames in the presence of a nonequilibrium
discharge. A number of different plasma discharges, including
thermal plasma discharge [11], dielectric barrier discharge [5],
nanosecond pulsed discharge [12], pulsed corona discharge
[13], radio frequency discharge [14], dc or low-frequency al-
ternating current discharge [15], and plasmatron [3], gliding
arc [16], and microwave discharge [17], have been investigated
for enhancing high-temperature thermal oxidation. A more
extensive review is available in [1].
Coupling high-temperature reactive flows with a nonequilib-
rium plasma discharge can lead to significant changes in the
formation of nitric oxide (NO), one of the most problematic
combustion effluents and a critical design parameter for all
practical combustion systems. The key mechanisms involved
in the NO chemistry for plasma discharges and methane flames
are shown in Table I. Generally, NO formation in conventional
combustion is due to four main processes [18], [19]: 1) thermal
(Zeldovich) mechanism, which occurs at high temperatures
because of the high energy required for dissociation of the ni-
trogen molecule (reactions 1, 2, and 3); 2) prompt mechanisms
with important intermediate species HCN and NH (reactions 4
and 5); 3) N
2
O mechanism, which involves third body collision
(reactions 6, 7, and 9); and 4) fuel-bound nitrogen mechanism,
where nitrogen is supplied from the fuel itself. NO can also be
removed by reacting with hydrocarbon radicals in rich flame
through a process known as “NO reburn” [20], of which some
of the key reactions are also listed in Table I. A slight increase
of hydrocarbons in a rich flame can lead to a drastic increase
in the reduction of NO. Atomic and molecular excited states
reactions also play an important role in formation and reduction
of NO [21], [22], and related reactions are shown in Table I.
In the case where no combustion is involved and there is
only a plasma discharge, formation of NO from air varies,
depending on the discharge system. For example, reaction 14
can be the principal NO formation pathway in pulsed dis-
charge with shorter time scales (10
−8
−10
−6
s) [23], while
reaction 16 is shown to be dominant in corona discharges [24].
For a variety of reduced electric fields, different percentages
0093-3813/$26.00 © 2009 IEEE
Authorized licensed use limited to: Michigan State University. Downloaded on December 8, 2009 at 14:23 from IEEE Xplore. Restrictions apply.