Iraqi, Syrian, and Palestinian Refugee Adolescents’ Beliefs About Parental
Authority Legitimacy and Its Correlates
Judith G. Smetana
University of Rochester
Ikhlas Ahmad
University of Jordan
Laura Wray-Lake
University of Rochester
This study examined intra- and interindividual variations in parental legitimacy beliefs in a sample of 883
Arab refugee adolescents (M
age
= 15.01 years, SD = 1.60), 277 Iraqis, 275 Syrians, and 331 Palestinians in
Amman, Jordan. Confirmatory factor analyses showed distinct latent factors for moral–conventional, pruden-
tial, and personal legitimacy items. Older adolescents rated legitimacy lower for personal issues, but higher
for prudential issues. Beliefs were associated with socioeconomic status (fathers’ education, family size), par-
ticularly for personal issues, but were more pervasively associated with displacement-related experiences.
Greater war trauma was associated with less prudential legitimacy for all youth and more authority legiti-
macy over moral–conventional issues for Syrian youth. Greater hopefulness was associated with more author-
ity legitimacy over all but personal issues.
Developmental scientists now agree that children
and adolescents are active agents in their socializa-
tion and that they evaluate and then act on their
beliefs and expectations (Grusec & Davidov, 2010;
Kuczynski, Parkin, & Pitman, 2015). Although ado-
lescents draw boundaries and reject parental control
over some issues, they believe that parents have the
legitimate authority—and indeed, that parents are
obligated—to make rules about many areas of
youth’s lives (Kakihara & Tilton-Weaver, 2009;
Smetana, 2000; Smetana & Asquith, 1994). Impor-
tantly, these beliefs are associated with behavioral
indicators of socialization, including compliance to
parental rules (Darling, Cumsille, & Martinez, 2007;
Keijsers & Laird, 2014; Kuhn & Laird, 2011), and
more broadly, with morality, identity, and auton-
omy development.
Although similar age trends and domain speci-
ficity in legitimacy beliefs have been found in dif-
ferent cultures, individual differences and
contextual influences also have been observed (re-
viewed in Smetana, 2011). The effects of cultural
values, economic hardship, neighborhood condi-
tions, and war exposure are complexly intertwined
when considering authority beliefs among refugee
youth. Large numbers of youth in the Middle East
have been displaced due to political and ethnic vio-
lence (Barber, 1999, 2014; Dubow, Huesmann, &
Boxer, 2009), yet little research has examined these
beliefs in such samples and their associations with
contextual factors. Parenting has been found to both
mediate and moderate the effects of displacement
and war-related trauma on Middle Eastern refugee
youth’s adjustment (Punam€ aki, Quota, & El Sarraj,
1997). Thus, studying youth’s interpretations of and
beliefs about parenting could contribute to an
understanding of both cross-cultural similarities
and variations in parenting beliefs, as well as the
factors that contribute to refugee youth’s healthy
social development. The present study addressed
these issues by examining parental authority beliefs
We are grateful to the University of Jordan for its financial
support of this project and to its President, Professor Dr. Ekhleif
Tarawneh, for his assistance in obtaining cooperation from the
participating schools. We thank the United Nations Relief and
Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in Jordan and Chief of the
Field Education program, Dr. Jihad Hamdan, and the principals
and teachers at all of the participating schools. We also thank
Farah Fayez, Yaser Nubani, and Sarah Alzyoud for their assis-
tance with translation.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to
Judith Smetana, CSP, Meliora Hall, RC 270266, University of
Rochester, Rochester, NY 14627. Electronic mail may be sent to
smetana@psych.rochester.edu.
© 2015 The Authors
Child Development © 2015 Society for Research in Child Development, Inc.
All rights reserved. 0009-3920/2015/8606-0024
DOI: 10.1111/cdev.12457
Child Development, November/December 2015, Volume 86, Number 6, Pages 2017–2033