58
Primary Constrained Condylar
Knee Arthroplasty for the
Arthritic Valgus Knee
Mark E. Easley, MD*; John N. Insall, MD**;
Giles R. Scuderi, MD**; and David D. Bullek, MD
†
CLINICAL ORTHOPAEDICS AND RELATED RESEARCH
Number 380, pp. 58–64
© 2000 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
The purpose of the current study was to review
results of primary constrained condylar knee
arthroplasty in elderly patients with genu val-
gum deformity. The hypotheses were: (1) con-
straint has no adverse effects in elderly patients;
(2) treating deformity with a constrained condy-
lar knee prosthesis in lieu of lateral ligament re-
lease avoids morbidity, particularly peroneal
nerve palsy and flexion instability; and (3)
press-fit noncemented stem extensions enhance
fixation of the cemented core components and
are not prone to loosening. Between 1988 and
1993, 44 consecutive primary Constrained
Condylar Knee prostheses were implanted in 37
patients (average age, 72.7 years) with an aver-
age valgus angle of 17.6. Indications for the
Constrained Condylar Knee implant were: el-
derly patients with genu valgum deformity and
medial collateral ligament incompetence. Out-
come was assessed prospectively using the Hos-
pital for Special Surgery and Knee Society scor-
ing systems; followup was by independent
observer. Clinical and radiographic followup
(average, 7.8 years) was available for 28 knees
(26 patients). The Hospital for Special Surgery
score improved from 52.2 to 89.6 points. The av-
erage Knee Society score and functional scores
improved from 27.4 and 32.4 points to 95.2 and
67.2 points, respectively. At followup, the aver-
age alignment based on anteroposterior radi-
ographs obtained with the patient weightbear-
ing was 5.3. No radiographic loosening,
prosthetic failures, peroneal nerve palsies, or
flexion instability occurred. No failures oc-
curred in the 11 patients (16 knees) who died be-
fore the latest followup. To the authors’ knowl-
edge, this is the largest reported series with the
longest reported followup of patients with pri-
mary Constrained Condylar Knee prostheses.
The use of the Constrained Condylar Knee
prosthesis for elderly patients with low physical
demands with genu valgum resulted in signifi-
cant pain relief and improved function.
Various techniques have been described to cor-
rect a fixed genu valgum deformity. Typically,
some type of a lateral soft tissue release with
either a posterior cruciate retaining or posterior
stabilized prosthesis has been used.
21,27
Occa-
sionally, balancing the medial and lateral col-
lateral structures requires extensive lengthen-
ing of the lateral side to match the medial side.
Significant lengthening of the lateral soft tissue
structures may result in peroneal nerve palsy
postoperatively,
1,21,24,27
flexion instability,
5,10,
12,23,25
or both. An alternative to lateral soft tis-
sue release is medial collateral advancement,
From the *Duke University Medical Center, Durham,
NC; the **Insall-Scott-Kelly Institute, Beth Israel Med-
ical Center-Singer Division, New York, NY; and the
†
Overlook Hospital, Westfield, NJ.
Reprint requests to Giles R. Scuderi, MD, 170 East End
Avenue, 4
th
Floor, New York, NY 10128.