PHYSICAL REVIEW E 97, 052802 (2018)
Island size distribution with hindered aggregation
Diego Luis González,
1 , *
Manuel Camargo,
2 , †
and Julián A. Sánchez
1 , ‡
1
Departamento de Física, Universidad del Valle, A.A. 25360, Cali, Colombia
2
CICBA, Universidad Antonio Nariño–Campus Farallones, Km 18 vía Cali-Jamundí, Cali, Colombia
(Received 9 February 2018; published 10 May 2018)
We study the effect of hindered aggregation on the island formation processes for a one-dimensional model
of epitaxial growth with arbitrary nucleus size i . In the proposed model, the attachment of monomers to islands
is hindered by an aggregation barrier, ǫ
a
, which decreases the hopping rate of monomers to the islands. As
ǫ
a
increases, the system exhibits a crossover between two different regimes; namely, from diffusion-limited
aggregation to attachment-limited aggregation. The island size distribution, P (s ), is calculated for different
values of ǫ
a
by a self-consistent approach involving the nucleation and aggregation capture kernels. The results
given by the analytical model are compared with those from kinetic Monte Carlo simulations, finding a close
agreement between both sets of data for all considered values of i and ǫ
a
. As the aggregation barrier increases,
the spatial effect of fluctuations on the density of monomers can be neglected and P (s ) smoothly approximates
to the limit distribution P (s ) = δ
s,i +1
. In the crossover regime the system features a complex and rich behavior,
which can be explained in terms of the characteristic timescales of different microscopic processes.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.97.052802
I. INTRODUCTION
Epitaxial growth (EG) has long been a subject of study
due to both its academic and industrial importance. From
an academic point of view, this out-of-equilibrium process is
interesting as it displays a rich and complex behavior arising
from the several timescales involved [1–14]. On the other hand,
an understanding of the microscopic mechanisms affecting
the growth process is a requirement to achieve an accurate
description of material properties in industrial applications. A
typical example of the latter is the use of atomic chains in
nanoscale devices, life sciences, and fuel cells [15–17] which
can be formed, for example, by using stepped surfaces [18,19]
or by anisotropic diffusion on two-dimensional substrates
[20–23].
In general terms, the microscopic mechanisms of EG in-
volve three basic processes: nucleation, aggregation, and trans-
port of basic growth units, usually referred to as monomers,
which may be atoms, molecules, or colloidal particles. Dur-
ing EG, monomers are deposited onto a flat substrate or a
stepped surface at a constant deposition rate, F . The latter
is well controlled in experimental setups and therefore can
be considered as a known parameter in theoretical models.
The time evolution of the deposition process is normally
described in terms of the coverage θ , which is defined as the
number of monomers per lattice site on the substrate at time
t . If evaporation of monomers from substrate is negligible,
then θ ≈ Ft . After its deposition, a monomer diffuses on the
substrate with (lateral) diffusion constant D until they nucleate
or aggregate. Nucleation occurs when a number of monomers
*
diego.luis.gonzalez@correounivalle.edu.co
†
manuel.camargo@uan.edu.co
‡
julian.a.sanchez@correounivalle.edu.co
form an island, i.e., a stable cluster, and the aggregation process
takes place when a monomer attaches to a previously nucleated
island.
A paramount concept in standard models of epitaxial growth
is that of the critical nucleus size i , which is defined as the size
of the largest unstable cluster, i.e., clusters with size larger
than i are static and stable. Consequently clusters with size
smaller than i + 1 are considered unstable and the monomers
belonging to such clusters can diffuse away with diffusion
constant D. Therefore, each monomer forming an unstable
cluster behaves as a free monomer. In most EG models,
nucleation and aggregation are instantaneous processes, i.e.,
monomers are incorporated to the clusters once they reach the
interaction range; in such a case, the aggregation belongs to the
diffusion-limited-aggregation (DLA) regime. Nevertheless, in
more realistic situations nucleation and/or aggregation could
be hindered by additional energy barriers which would increase
the time required for each reaction.
For instance, experiments on nucleation and growth of
Ge islands on a Pb overlayer covering a Si(111) surface
suggest that such a barrier could appear due to strain [24–27].
Also, nucleation hindered by attachment barriers has been
observed in Fe deposition on graphene [28] and in metal
(111) homoepitaxial systems [29,30]. Similarly, attachment
barriers must be considered to properly explain the formation
of graphene sheets on metal [31–34] and oxide [35] substrates.
In the former case, individual graphene islands spread at a
constant rate, suggesting that their growth is controlled by the
attachment rate of carbon adatoms to the island edges.
Motivated by previous theoretical [2,3,12,14,36–46] and
experimental [21,22,47–51] studies, in this work we propose a
one-dimensional model in which the aggregation of monomers
is hindered by an additional attachment barrier ǫ
a
. As explained
in the next sections, this barrier decreases the hopping rate of
monomers to islands. Thus, for large barriers the monomers
2470-0045/2018/97(5)/052802(11) 052802-1 ©2018 American Physical Society