Implementing Pull Manufacturing in
Make-To-Order Environments
Mohammed ALMANEI, Omogbai OLEGHE, Mohamed AFY-SHARARAH and
Konstantinos SALONITIS
1
School of Aerospace, Transport and Manufacturing, Cranfield University, Cranfield
MK43 0AL, UK
Abstract. The demand for increasing product variety and customization has forced
many companies to adopt a make-to-order (MTO) strategy. Traditional push-type
MTO companies suffer from unstable demands, struggling to deliver on time,
making them consider the utilization of pull systems to control production. In the
present paper, an overview of pull systems in MTO environments is presented.
Moreover, a discrete event simulation (DES) model of an MTO company in the
printing and packaging industrial sector was developed and validated, in order to
identify areas for improvement. DES was also used in order to evaluate the
feasibility of implementing three types of pull systems: kanban, CONstant-Work-
In-Process (CONWIP) and Paired Overlapping Loops of Cards with Authorizations
(POLCA). The main performance indicators measured were the average WIP and
the average throughput time of parts. The key findings of this project for the case
study were: a) kanban is inapplicable for the current routing of parts; b) a CONWIP
strategy improves the shop floor performance, but only when extra capacity is added
to the extrusion workstation; c) production based on POLCA leads to the blockage
of the system due to the existence of multi-routes and undirected routing.
Keywords. Lean Manufacturing, Discrete event simulation, Make-to-order.
1. Introduction
Lean Manufacturing is well established in the manufacturing sector as a philosophy
focused on reducing all types of waste, which consequently improves quality and reduces
production time and cost. The ultimate objective of lean is to achieve a continuous flow
[1]. Continuous workflow reduces many kinds of production waste, for example, product
waiting times, and increases value to the customer. Practice has shown that lean is easily
adapted to make-to-stock organizations where the production demand can be predicted
quite accurately. However, the increasing demand for high mix and low volume products
has forced many companies to adopt the make-to-order (MTO) approach [2]. Such
companies must cope with unstable customer demand and their main challenge is to meet
such demand on time. It has been shown that high mix and low volume producers find it
difficult to adopt lean strategies, such as Kanban and one-piece flow effectively [3] and
have to rely on more traditional practices based on push-type production systems and
functional layouts and implementation of simple Material Resource Planning (MRP) [4].
However, implementing pull production helps keep under control inventory as well
as controlling throughput times by establishing a work in progress (WIP) cap [5], [6].
Nowadays companies are fortunate to be able to opt from many different pull systems,
Advances in Manufacturing Technology XXXV
M. Shafik and K. Case (Eds.)
© 2022 The authors and IOS Press.
This article is published online with Open Access by IOS Press and distributed under the terms
of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License 4.0 (CC BY-NC 4.0).
doi:10.3233/ATDE220613
334