Note
IEEE COMMITTEE ON MAN AND RADIATION—COMAR TECHNICAL
INFORMATION STATEMENT RADIOFREQUENCY SAFETY AND
UTILITY SMART METERS
Jerrold T. Bushberg, Kenneth R. Foster, James B. Hatfield, Arthur Thansandote, and Richard A. Tell*
Abstract—This Technical Information Statement describes Smart
Meter technology as used with modern electric power metering
systems and focuses on the radio frequency (RF) emissions associ-
ated with their operation relative to human RF exposure limits.
Smart Meters typically employ low power (-1 W or less) transmit-
ters that wirelessly send electric energy usage data to the utility
company several times per day in the form of brief, pulsed emis-
sions in the unlicensed frequency bands of 902-928 MHz and
2.4-2.48 GHz or on other nearby frequencies. Most Smart Meters
operate as wireless mesh networks where each Smart Meter can
communicate with other neighboring meters to relay data to a data
collection point in the region. This communication process includes
RF emissions from Smart Meters representing energy usage as well
as the relaying of data from other meters and emissions associated
with maintaining the meter's hierarchy within the wireless network.
As a consequence, most Smart Meters emit RF pulses throughout
the day, more at certain times and less at others. However, the duty
cycle associated with all of these emissions is very small, typically
less than 1%, and most of the time far less than 1%, meaning that
most Smart Meters actually transmit RF fields for only a few mi-
nutes per day at most. The low peak power of Smart Meters and
the very low duty cycles lead to the fact that accessible RF fields
near Smart Meters are far below both U.S. and international RF
safety limits whether judged on the basis of instantaneous peak
power densities or time-averaged exposures. This conclusion holds
for Smart Meters alone or installed in large banks of meters.
Health Phys. 108(3):388–391; 2015
Key words: electromagnetic fields; radiation, non-ionizing; radio-
frequency; safety standards
INTRODUCTION
THE INSTITUTE of Electrical and Electronics Engineers—
Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (IEEE EMBS)
Committee on Man and Radiation (COMAR) acknowledges
public concern about the safety of exposure to radio fre-
quency (RF) energy from Smart Meters, which are new-
generation electric utility meters that are being installed in
many parts of the world.
This Technical Information Statement describes the
Smart Meter technology and the levels of RF emissions from
the meters in relation to U.S. and international RF safety limits
and in comparison to RF signal levels from other sources.
BACKGROUND
Smart Meters (a term used both by industry and the
public) are electric utility meters that have advanced com-
munication capabilities that allow periodic collection of us-
age data by the utility. In comparison to a slightly earlier
generation of wireless-enabled meters that can be read re-
motely by technicians driving through a neighborhood,
Smart Meters engage in two-way communication with the
utility, allowing frequent (hourly or better) reading of the
meters and other functions. Eventually the technology could
be extended to other utility meters as well, but at present it is
mainly limited to electric meters.
Electric utilities have installed Smart Meters and their
associated Advanced Metering Infrastructure (AMI) in many
places around the world, partly in response to government
incentives to adopt time-of-use pricing as an economic tool
to improve the efficiency of the electric power grid by smooth-
ing out the peaks and valleys of electricity demand through-
out the day. AMI systems can also provide consumers with
detailed data about household power consumption and pro-
mote energy conservation.
While they vary considerably in design with different
vendors, most Smart Meter systems rely on wireless transmis-
sion of data using standard wireless networking technologies.
(A few systems send data over power lines or use some other
means of communication not involving wireless transmis-
sions.) Because of the resulting potential for exposure to
RF energy, some citizens have raised concerns about possi-
ble health risks from the use of Smart Meters. This Technical
Information Statement addresses those concerns.
*University of California, Davis School of Medicine, 2315 Stockton
Blvd., FSSB 2500, Sacramento, CA 95817.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
For correspondence contact: Jerrold T. Bushberg at the above
address, or email at jtbushberg@ucdavis.edu.
(Manuscript accepted 10 September 2014)
0017-9078/15/0
Copyright © 2015 Health Physics Society
DOI: 10.1097/HP.0000000000000217
388 www.health-physics.com
Copyright © 2015 Health Physics Society. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.