SPECIAL TOPIC
A Web-Based, Integrated Simulation System for
Craniofacial Surgical Planning
Stephen A. Schendel, M.D.,
D.D.S.
Kevin Montgomery, Ph.D.
Palo Alto, Calif.
Background: Advances in computing over the last 10 years have rapidly improved
imaging and simulation in health care. Implementation of three-dimensional pro-
tocols and image fusion techniques are moving diagnosis, treatment planning, and
teaching to a next-generation paradigm. In addition, decreasing cost and increasing
availability make generalized use of these techniques possible.
Methods: In this article, the authors present a Web-based, integrated simulation
system for craniofacial surgical planning and treatment. Image fusion technology
was utilized to create a realistic virtual image that can be manipulated in real time.
The resultant data can then be shared over the Internet by distantly located prac-
titioners.
Results: Initial use of this system proved to be beneficial from a planning standpoint
and to be accurate as to the reliability of landmark identification. Additional case
studies are needed to further document the results of actual surgical simulation.
Conclusion: This technology presents significant advantages in surgical planning
and education, both of which can improve patient safety and outcomes. (Plast.
Reconstr. Surg. 123: 1099, 2009.)
A
lthough a number of systems have been
developed over the past three decades for
computer-based surgical planning,
1–20
most
have not enjoyed widespread adoption and use
clinically beyond academic publications. This lim-
ited use is directly related to the cost of the system
and limited availability on the one hand and the
difficulty of use on the other. Systems that are not
realistic enough and real-time based inhibit clini-
cians from taking the time to master the system, as
initial use is learning intensive. In addition, the sys-
tems are frequently not user friendly for clinicians.
Computing advancements in the last 10 years
have rapidly improved imaging and simulation in
the health care field. The adoption of three-di-
mensional imaging protocols and the power of the
Internet are moving diagnosis, treatment plan-
ning, outcome evaluation, and teaching to the
next-generation paradigm. Image fusion combin-
ing computed tomography/cone beam computed
tomography, magnetic resonance imaging, and
surface image scans enables the generation of a
patient-specific electronic model in the real world,
which magnifies the potential for truly patient-
centric care. Lastly, these systems can be Web-based,
which both increases availability and decreases cost.
The virtual patient can then be studied and treat-
ment protocols developed.
Improved results in surgery with the use of vir-
tual reality may be obtained secondary to improved
precision and reduced complications. Computer-
based surgical simulation also has proven benefit
in teaching and the acquisition of surgical skills
and their objective evaluation. A Web-based vir-
tual reality system allows the interaction of multi-
ple users at a distance and immediate dissemina-
tion of application.
Correctly planning and accurately predicting
surgical outcome is paramount in facial surgery.
Gossett et al.
21
have outlined a threefold purpose
for computer-simulated predictions: (1) guide the
treatment to the desired result, (2) give the patient
a reasonable preview of the outcome, and (3)
serve as a communication tool between specialists,
such as orthodontist and surgeon. It is easy to see
that this can be expanded to include other pro-
fessionals involved in patient care. Traditionally,
the visual treatment objective has been done by
manual creation of simulated treatment tracings
based on cephalometric radiographs. The first
From the Division of Plastic Surgery, Stanford University.
Received for publication March 15, 2008; accepted June 18,
2008.
Copyright ©2009 by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons
DOI: 10.1097/PRS.0b013e318199f653
Disclosure: The authors are consultants for
3dMD, which makes a surface scanner.
www.PRSJournal.com 1099