JSPN Vol. 11, No. 1, January, 2006 57
Blackwell Publishing, Ltd. Oxford, UK JSPN Journal for Specialists in Pediatric Nursing 1088-145X © 2005 by Nursecom, Inc. January 2006 11 1 COLUMNS Ask the Expert
Ask the Expert
Sexual Health Education Disparities in Asian American Adolescents
Tsui-Sui Kao
Column Editor: Betsy M. McDowell
Ask the Expert provides research-based answers to practice
questions submitted by JSPN readers.
Question: I have noticed that there are increasing
numbers of Asian American adolescents in the United
States. Even though Asian American youth are doing
great academically, their level of sexual health-related
knowledge is not explicitly known or understood because
of the differences in their cultural backgrounds. What
do I need to know in order to ensure that my assess-
ment of their sexual health knowledge is culturally
responsive?
Tsui-Sui Kao responds: Asian Americans comprise
close to 4.2% of the total U.S. population. Research on
the health status of Asian Pacific Americans (APA) often
analyzes the population as one homogeneous group;
however, the APA community includes more than 30
diverse ethnic subpopulations that vary by national
origin, language, culture, citizenship, and economic
status. The main subgroups include Chinese, Japanese,
Korean, Filipino, Vietnamese, Asian Indian, and other
cultures from Southeast Asia (U.S. Department of
Commerce [USDOC], 2000). Even though as a whole,
Asian Americans seem to have comparable educational
backgrounds and median family incomes with Cauca-
sian Americans, Asian Americans tend to have more
family members working at the same time to maintain
their financial status and lifestyle. It is important to
note that 14% of the APA population lives below the
poverty line, compared to 13% of the U.S. population,
and that Asian Americans are less likely to use federal
or state-funded health care programs such as Medicaid
(National Asian Pacific American Women’s Forum
[NAPAWF], 2005).
Asian Americans often are perceived as a model
minority, appearing to have abundant resources. In
reality, their health is compromised by this misconcep-
tion, and their health problems are often blamed on
the conservative nature of their cultures. Healthcare
disparities exist not only in new immigrants but also in
the subsequent generations of Asian American children.
Most Asian American children are immigrants them-
selves or are children of immigrants who straddle two
cultures. Few studies are available to help nurses see
some of the problems that Asian American adolescents
encounter as a result of this bicultural identification.
Nurse professionals confront increasing challenges to
care for this vulnerable population, especially with the
cultural sensitivity to sexual health issues (Kibria, 2002).
Nurses must be cognizant of the importance of Asian
Americans’ family-centered cultural values, more
specifically the taboo against sex education, and the
possible impacts of bicultural straddling. Grunbaum,
Lowery, Kann, and Pateman (2000) noted that Asian
American adolescents tend to delay sexual intercourse,
but that once sexually active, they were as likely to have
used alcohol or drugs or fail to use a condom during
intercourse as any other ethnic group. These factors put
them at greater risk for compromised sexual health;
therefore, it is important for pediatric nurses to assess
the sexual health of all Asian American adolescents.
Asian American Adolescents’ Sexual Health
Studies show that Asian American adolescents tend
to delay the onset of sexual intercourse compared to
other ethnic groups (Grunbaum et al., 2000; Horan
& DiClemente, 1993; Schuster, Bell, & Kanouse, 1996;
Schuster, Bell, Nakajima, & Kanouse, 1998; Upchurch,
Levy-Storms, Sucoff, & Aneshensel, 1998); however,
they are less likely to receive sexual health-related
services prior to and even after becoming sexually
active (National Asian Women’s Health Organization
[NAWHO], 1997; Schuster et al., 1996) than other popu-
lation groups. As a result, Asian American women tend
to be diagnosed with more advanced stages of cervical
cancer and breast cancer than Caucasian American
women (Frisch & Goodman, 2000; Hedeen, White, &
Taylor, 1999), and cervical cancer is the leading cause
of death for Vietnamese American women (Ishida,
2001). Furthermore, new technology and research show
that cervical cancer is actually caused by the human
papillomavirus (HPV) (Ordonez, Espinosa, Sanchez-