Throughput Distribution Analysis of Return Link
Multi-Gateway Interference Cancellation Strategies
for Multi-Beam Broadband Satellite Systems
F. Lombardo, A.Vanelli-Coralli, E.A. Candreva, and G.E. Corazza
DEIS/ARCES - University of Bologna, Viale Risorgimento 2, 40136 Bologna, Italy
e-mail: {flombardo,ecandreva}@arces.unibo.it, {alessandro.vanelli, giovanni.corazza}@unibo.it
Abstract—This paper presents the study of the throughput
distribution for several interference cancellation and gateway co-
operation strategies for the return link of a multi-gateway multi-
beam broadband satellite system. Different coverage schemes and
frequency reuse patterns are considered, taking into account
practical system parameters and antenna design. Aim of this
work is to provide a tool to ease the seek of design trade-offs,
as between spectral efficiency and system complexity. This is ad-
dressed showing the distribution of SINR (signal-to-interference
plus noise ratio) and the throughput distribution considering
different interference cancellation techniques, leveraging on dif-
ferent degrees of cooperation between gateways.
Index Terms—Interference Cancellation, Satellite Systems,
Multi-Gateway, Multi-Beam, Throughput Distribution.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Satellite communications are undergoing a series of rapid
innovations: satellite coverage is instrumental to provide ubiq-
uitous connectivity, and the user bit-rate requirements are
increasing, as a consequence of the evolution in services and
users habits. This situation is stimulating significant research
efforts to improve the efficiency of satellite communications,
and to overcome present-day liming factors.
Moreover satellite systems are leveraging on both a conver-
gence and a competition with terrestrial networks, in the aim
of meeting the requirements of a digital and fully connected
citizenship. This has further boosted the requirement for
the satellite capacity, and several advanced signal processing
techniques are being studied to meet such requirements by
improving the spectral efficiency.
Current multi-beam satellites are heavily affected and lim-
ited by the inter-beam interference, which is an unavoidable
consequence of the overlap of beam patterns. Present-day
typical solution is to employ a frequency reuse pattern, in order
to provide a spatial separation between beams operated on the
same frequency. Several studies, as [1]-[3], on the other hand,
are focusing on a more promising approach, i.e. to operate
with full frequency reuse and processing the signal in order
to mitigate the interference. In this way the throughput is
increased by several times, at the only expense of a slightly
decreased availability [2]. Nevertheless, these advanced signal
processing strategies pose additional challenges to the satellite
network design, since the processing is performed at the
gateway (GW) side, and it has to be designed considering a
limited information exchange amongst gateways. As a matter
of fact, the feeder link is one of the system’s bottlenecks in
case of high throughput multi-beam satellite systems, since
it represents the mean to carry the entire aggregated user
generated traffic from the satellite towards the on ground core
network. For this reason the total traffic at the satellite is
split on different feeder links each one feeding a different and
geographically separated gateway.
In this paper, building upon [1]-[4], we analyze the impact
on user throughput of different interference cancellation (IC)
strategies, requiring various levels of gateway coordination.
We will first consider a simpler MF (matched filter) processing
and a MMSE (minimum mean square error) processing, and
then we will evolve up to a centralized MMSE-SIC (successive
interference cancellation), the focus being mainly on intra-
GW and inter-GW interference cancellation. Performance is
provided for a realistic antenna pattern and actual values of
number of beams and gateways in terms of user SINR PDF
(probability density function) and throughput CDF (cumulative
distribution function).
In the following, we will start with definition of the refer-
ence scenarios and the system model. We will then discuss
interference cancellation and gateway cooperation strategies,
evaluating and comparing them.
II. SCENARIOS DEFINITION
The focus of this paper is on the return link of a broadband
system based on a Ka-band geostationary satellite having B
beams, obtained by a single feed per beam antenna architec-
ture.
Concerning the ground segment, two assumptions on the
GWs are of fundamental importance for this analysis: we
assume that the GWs are connected through a high-capacity
network, to allow for the information exchange between them,
and we assume that each gateway is able to control N
BGW
beams, due to the available feeder link bandwidth.
Users are assumed to be randomly located within each beam
and that an MF-TDMA channelisation [5] is adopted with a
GC'12 Workshop: The 8th Broadband Wireless Access Workshop
978-1-4673-4941-3/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE 95