Structural Analysis of Historic Construction – D’Ayala & Fodde (eds)
© 2008Taylor & Francis Group, London, ISBN 978-0-415-46872-5
Experiences of consolidation on archaeological UNESCO sites in Sultanate
of Oman: The Fortress of Al Balid and the Citadel of Sumhuram
Marco Andreini, Chiara Cei, Giorgio Mariani & Mauro Sassu
Department of Structural Engineering, University of Pisa, Italy
ABSTRACT: Taking the opportunity to collaborate with the archaeological groups a staff of structural engineers
has been organized to attend the consolidation works on the UNESCO sites of Khor Rori and Al Balid (Sultanate
of Oman).
Starting from early 2005 a series of missions have been managed to restore the ancient city walls of Sumhuram
in the site of Khor Rori and other structural elements, establishing the appropriate procedures and co-ordinating
the workmen involved during excavations, together with the archaeological Italian Mission To Oman of the
University of Pisa.The site is characterized by a cave of limestone, used for the city walls, and a soil with high
percentage of clay, used to infill the block joints and the space between the external stone faces. The two faces of
walls were not well transversally connected and the internal filling was made by clay soil: during the rain seasons
the filling reduced its consistence causing progressive collapse situations. The rebuilding activity of walls has
been involved to give safety along the path for visitors, replying the same texture of the stones adding internal
transverse stone connections (“orthostati”), accompanied by a proper choice of the mortar (colour, composition
and strength) to reply the original joint aspect and filling the walls with a mix with superior permeability. The
re-constructed walls has been separated by the original with a geotextile foil. A simplified analytical model has
been then prepared to evaluate the increment of safety level due to the consolidations, assigning the shape of the
collapse surfaces and adopting a simplified approach of limit analysis.
In the same period members the group have been involved to consolidate the Fortress in UNESCO site of Al
Balid in the nearby (Salalah – Sultanate of Oman) erected about 1100 A.D.; the excavations was managed by the
Institute of Archaeology of the Missouri University. In this case the absence of mortar did not cause collapses,
while the resistance has been ensured by the gravity loads and friction of stones; the collapse has been originated
by the loss of permeability of the external wall faces due to the progressive filling of joint by soil. Therefore
consolidations consisted to excavate and immediately rebuild the collapsed walls with the same blocks down,
after the substitution of the earth behind the external layers remaking a drainage made of mixed gravel and
small stones selected on site to ensure an efficient washout during rain seasons. Unoriginal ramps to penetrate
inside the Fortress has been removed with accurate excavation, reducing transverse loads due to the unbalanced
earth pressure. A simplified model to evaluate the behaviour of walls has been performed to describe failure
mechanism and the influence of the main physical and geometrical parameters.
1 AL BALEED FORTRESS: RESTORATION
ACTIVITIES
The Fortress of Al Balid, located in Salalah (Oman), is
originated around XI century AD and is composed by a
texture of dry stone walls partially collapsed or covered
by sand and lime. The construction is organized on a
rectangular plan of about 70 × 60 meters, with circular
towers on the edges and near the gates. The structural
consolidation works has been started in early 2007 and
has been divided into two main categories:
1. Stone and earth ramps.
2. Local reconstructions of collapsing masonry panels.
1.1 Stone and earth ramps
Eight stone and earth ramps has been individuated
around the external walls of the fortress, made inten-
tionally during previous works or caused by natural
deposit due to environmental effects.
It has been necessary to remove the ramps to show
the original walls, avoiding an unbalanced excavation
(exterior-interior); moreover some ramp could be pre-
cious to remove materials from the inner part of the
fortress.
One of them has been completely remove, except a
zone of respect in front of the fortress, to prevent rota-
tion collapse of the perimeter walls of the fortress.
1481