88 Original article
Radiological outcome of proximal femoral varus
osteotomy for the treatment of lateral pillar group-C
Legg–Calve ´ –Perthes disease
M. Cemalettin Aksoy
a
, M. Cenk Cankus
b
, Ahmet Alanay
a
, Muharrem Yazici
a
,
Omur Caglar
a
and A. Mumtaz Alpaslan
a
Results from 26 hips of 24 Legg–Calve ´ –Perthes disease
patients were evaluated retrospectively. There were 22
male and two female patients in the study group. The mean
age of the patients was 8.3 years and the mean follow-up
was 13.03 years. All the patients were older than 6 years of
age and all of them had lateral pillar group C hips. The
patients were treated with intertrochanteric uniplanar varus
osteotomy. All the patients were mature at the time of the
last evaluation. Radiological end results were evaluated
according to Stulberg’s classification. Six hips healed with
spherical congruency (Stulberg class 1 or 2), 19 with
aspherical congruency (Stulberg class 3 or 4) and one with
aspherical incongruency (Stulberg class 5). Six of 14 hips
treated before 9 years of age healed with spherical
congruency but all hips treated after 9 years of age
healed with Stulberg class 3, 4 or 5 results. Trochanteric
overgrowth was evident in 20 hips. The results of this
radiological outcome study showed that Herring class C
hips treated with proximal femoral varus osteotomy had a
poor outcome, especially after 9 years of age in this group
of patients. J Pediatr Orthop B 14:88–91
c
2005 Lippincott
Williams & Wilkins.
Journal of Pediatric Orthopaedics B 2005, 14:88–91
Keywords: Legg–Calve ´ –Perthes disease, treatment, varus osteotomy
a
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Hacettepe University Faculty
of Medicine, Ankara and
b
Department of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, Sani
Konukoglu Medical Center, Gaziantep, Turkey.
Correspondence and requests for reprints to M. Cemalettin Aksoy, Angora Evleri,
Ruyalar Cad., Masal Sok., e-2 blok, no# 31, 06530, Beysukent, Ankara, Turkey.
Tel: + 90 312 305 1793; fax: + 90 312 310 0161;
e-mail: caksoy@hacettepe.edu.tr
Introduction
The treatment of severe Legg–Calve´–Perthes disease
(LCPD), especially after the age of 6 years, is still a
challenge. The main aim of treatment is to change the
natural history of the disease and provide a good long-term
outcome. Numerous radiographic classification systems
have been proposed for LCPD [1–4]. The purpose of all
classification systems is to predict the natural history of
the disease and aid in selecting a treatment modality.
Herring’s lateral pillar classification has been shown to be
easy to use and reliable [2,5,6]. The prognosis of Herring
group C hips, especially at older ages, is relatively poor.
Proximal femoral varus osteotomy is advocated for the
treatment of these hips [7,8]. The aim of this treatment is
to contain the femoral head in the acetabulum and provide
an optimum environment for healing [9]. The results of
this treatment, however, are still debatable. In the current
study, we evaluated the radiological outcome of proximal
femoral varus osteotomy in patients with Herring group C
hips and who were older than 6 years of age.
Materials and methods
Results from 26 hips of 24 patients with Herring group C
Legg–Calve´–Perthes disease (LCPD) treated with uni-
planar, intertrochanteric varus osteotomy, older than 6
years of age and who had lateral pillar group C hips were
evaluated retrospectively. Patients who had lateral pillar
group C hips treated conservatively or with other
methods were not included in the study. The decision
to operate was based on clinical and radiological risk factors
and the surgeon’s discretion. All the hips had lateral
subluxation (considered present if more than 15% of the
ossified femoral epiphysis was uncontained by the acet-
abulum or Shenton’s line was broken). Lateral calcification
was observed in eight hips, Gage’s sign was observed in
three hips and horizontal alignment of the growth plate was
present in 14 hips. There were 22 male and two female
patients in the group. There were 17 left hips and nine right
hips. Both hips of the two bilaterally affected patients were
treated in the same way. The mean age of the patients at
the onset of the disease was 8.3 years (range, 7–11). The
age of the patients was less than 9 years in 13 cases. All
patients had Herring group C hips and they were at the
initial or fragmentation stage of the disease at the time of
surgery. Herring’s lateral pillar classification defines the
lateral pillar as the lateral 15–30% of the femoral head [2].
Group C hips are defined if less than 50% of the lateral pillar
is intact in anteroposterior (AP) pelvis radiographs during
the fragmentation phase of the disease. The minimum
follow-up in all patients was 10 years and the mean follow-
up was 13.03 years (range, 10–20).
Containment of the ossified epiphysis in the abduction
position was confirmed in all patients before the surgery
1060-152X c 2005 Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Copyright © Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.