*
Corresponding author: khondoker.billah@utsa.edu
Urban Intersections and Traffic Safety in the City of San Antonio
Qasim Adegbite, Khondoker Billah
*
, Hatim Sharif, and Samer Dessouky
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of Texas at San Antonio, San Antonio, TX 78249
Abstract. Intersections are high-risk locations on roadways and often experience high incidence of crashes.
Better understanding of the factors contributing to crashes and deaths at intersections is crucial. This study
analyzed the factors related to crash incidence and crash severity at intersections in San Antonio for crashes
from 2013 to 2017 and identified hotspot locations based on crash frequency and crash rates. Binary logistic
regression model was considered for the analysis using crash severity as the response variable. Factors
found to be significantly associated with the severity of intersection crashes include age of driver, day of the
week, month, road alignment, and traffic control system. The crashes occurred predominantly in the high-
density center of the city (downtown area). Overall, the identification of risk factors and their impact on
crash severity would be helpful for road safety policymakers to develop proactive mitigation plans to reduce
the frequency and severity of intersection crashes.
1 Introduction
Road intersections are one of the most dangerous
locations in a roadway network as they are the
convergent spots for vehicles and people moving in
opposite paths. They often impose a major responsibility
on road users to make an informed decision on when to
cross the road to forestall unsafe situations. This part of
the road has one of the most complicated traffic
situations that motorists come across. Negligent high
speeding drivers who often disregard traffic signals
further compounds the problem [1]. In the United States,
about one-quarter of road fatalities and about half of all
traffic injuries over the last several years are attributed to
intersections [2]. Intersection crashes account for more
than 40% of all crashes in the United States [3]. A study
examining the characteristics of 787,236 motor vehicle
intersection crashes from 2005 through 2007, as listed in
the dataset from the National Motor Vehicle Crash
Causation Survey [4], showed that 96% of intersection
crashes had critical factors attributed to drivers and less
than 3% had critical factors were related to the vehicle or
environment [4]. Ensuring safety of road intersections is
a complicated issue and cannot always be mitigated by
barely changing/adding signals and signs. A more
sustainable solution can be achieved by a national
comprehensive program of improved pedestrian safety
and vehicle intersection management [4]. Proper
identification of intersections associated with high crash
rate is vital to reduce future crash occurrence. As of
2016, Texas has the highest number of fatal crashes in
the United States; 3,406 crashes resulting in 3,776 deaths
in that year. This is over 5% increase over 2015 figures
of 3,226 fatality crashes and 3,582 deaths. There was
also a 5.09% increase in total miles traveled in 2016
(271.263 billion) compared to 2015 (258.122 billion).
Over 800 of these deaths occurred at intersections or
were related to an intersection. Bexar County, where San
Antonio is located, had the 3rd highest totals in Texas in
2016, with 52,633 crashes and 220 deaths because of the
crashes [5]. Several factors contribute to intersection
crashes including driver related factors, vehicle related
factors, environment and road-related factors. Driver
errors are mostly human related factors which include
those committed while under the influence of alcohol, or
otherwise violating traffic rules and regulations, and
errors committed due to lack of training. Road-related
factors include traffic characteristics e.g. traffic volume,
geometric design of the intersections, traffic control
measures, state of line markings and signage, and surface
and light condition [6]. Environment-related factors,
such as weather conditions and natural lighting
conditions are mostly considered external to human
factors as they are beyond human control. Another
identified problem is the difficulty of many drivers in
judging gaps in high-speed traffic situation on a divided
highway with many lanes, as well as drivers trying to do
left-turn or cross into a divided highway [7]. Human
factors are the main cause of over 90% of car crash
incidents [8].
The viewpoint of science of safety has shifted due to
the evolution of data science. The focus is now on data
and analysis rather than sole dependence on standards as
stated in FHWA’s Highway Safety Improvement
Program Manual. For data analysis and safety
consideration, three to five years of crash data is the
most common time frame for good data representation.
Less than five years data might be good enough for some
cases. But a smaller sample size does not adequately
represent the data in general and might require statistical
adjustment [9]. The need for field assessment of
intersection spots has been identified as a major activity
© The Authors, published by EDP Sciences. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0
(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
MATEC Web of Conferences 271, 06003 (2019) https://doi.org/10.1051/matecconf/201927106003
Tran-SET 2019