Multi-frequency Integration Algorithm of Contrast Source Inversion
Method for Microwave Breast Tumor Detection*
Hiroki Sato
1
and Shouhei Kidera
1
Abstract— Microwave mammography is one of the most
promising alternatives to X-ray-based breast cancer detection
techniques, where a malignant tumor has a certain level of
dielectric property contrast compared with those in normal
tissues. However, the inverse problem of reconstructing complex
permittivity is a non-linear and ill-posed problem, and the
appropriate selection of such algorithms is the key to the
success of microwave mammography. The contrast source
inversion (CSI) method is the most promising solution to
the above problem, where the iterative procedure does not
require a computationally expensive forward solver, like the
finite difference time domain (FDTD) method. However, the
conventional CSI method assumes a non-dispersive dielectric
model, while breast or other human tissues have a non-
negligible dispersive property. To address this problem, this
paper introduces an extended CSI method, which is suitable for
dispersive medium and in which multi-frequency integration
is introduced to enhance the reconstruction accuracy. The
FDTD numerical test, which uses a realistic breast phantom
via magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), demonstrates that
our proposed method efficiently enhances the reconstruction
accuracy even in dispersive medium.
I. INTRODUCTION
Recent reports from the World Cancer Research Fund have
revealed that breast cancer has become one of the most
widely diagnosed cancers in women [1]. Microwave-based
breast cancer detection, known as microwave mammography,
is one of the promising options for frequent screening
for cancer, which may be used as an alternative to the
traditional X-ray mammography, ultrasound, and magnetic
resonance imaging (MRI) in terms of cost, compactness, and
safety. While X-ray mammography is the most commonly
used imaging modality, it has a serious risk because of X-
ray exposure to normal cells [2]. Ultrasound imaging has
some advantages in terms of cost, portability, and suitability,
especially for women with dense breasts [3]. The MRI-based
modality has disadvantages in terms of its high cost and the
large equipment required [4].
Microwave mammography is based on the clinical fact that
there is a significant dielectric property contrast between nor-
mal and malignant tissue in breasts at microwave frequencies.
M. Lazebnik et al. demonstrated that there is a significant
dielectric property contrast between normal and malignant
tissue when measuring excised breast tissue specimens [5].
J. D. Shea et al. also revealed that the dispersion property
*This research and development work was supported by the MIC/SCOPE
162103102.
1
H. Sato and S. Kidera are with Graduate School of Informatics
and Engineering, University of Electro-Communications, Tokyo, Japan
kidera@uec.ac.jp
and fitting parameters using the single-pole Debye model
[4] for the complex permittivity of breast tissue are from
0.5 to 3.5 GHz [6]. Microwave imaging algorithms are
mainly divided into two categories: the radar-based approach
and the tomographic approach. Studies have shown that
[7] the space-time beamforming-based radar approach has
successfully demonstrated its effectiveness by processing a
number of tumor reflections. However, this method suffers
from a lower contrast image when the malignant tumor is
buried in the fibroglandular tissue, which has the same level
of dielectric property as cancer.
In contrast, the tomographic approach is considered more
promising because a complex dielectric map can be recon-
structed by solving the domain integral equation. However,
the above integral equation cannot be solved easily because
it is non-linear and an ill-posed problem. In particular,
conventional Born approximation-based methods, such as
diffraction tomography [8], suffer from inaccuracy in dealing
with the dielectric property map that has a much higher
contrast than the background medium. Among the numerous
inverse scattering algorithms, the distorted Born iterative
method (DBIM) is one of the most promising algorithms
because it updates the background profile to maintain the
linearity of the problem. Some literature has shown that
the DBIM offers accurate results even for dispersive breast
medium, including cancer [9], [10], [11]. However, the
DBIM basically requires a forward solver in each iterative
step, and it would take an enormous amount of computation,
especially for dealing with a three-dimensional problem.
Considering this background, we focused on the contrast
source inversion (CSI) method [12], which also solves the
non-linear integral equation by iteration steps. However, the
CSI does not require a computationally expensive forward
solver, such as FDTD; instead, it simultaneously solves the
state and data equation. In addition, a multiple frequency
strategy for the CSI method, such as frequency hopping,
was developed for accuracy enhancement in refs. [13], [14].
However, there are very few studies that have focused on
the CSI method and that dealt with a frequency-dependent
dielectric object, such as breasts or other human tissues.
To address this problem, this paper introduces a multi-
frequency integration scheme for the CSI method for dis-
persive breast medium [13]. This method first reconstructs
the complex permittivity map for each frequency using
the traditional CSI method, and the frequency-dependent
characteristic is sequentially determined by the single-pole
Debye model. In addition, this method integrates the multi-
frequency CSI outputs by considering the Debye curve using
978-1-5386-1311-5/19/$31.00 ©2019 IEEE 1863