55
Harvard Educational Review Vol. 89 No. 1 Spring 2019
Copyright © by the President and Fellows of Harvard College
The Practice of Listening to Children:
The Challenges of Hearing Children
Out in an Adult-Regulated World
HAENY S. YOON
Teachers College, Columbia University
TRAN NGUYEN TEMPLETON
University of North Texas
In this research article, Haeny Yoon and Tran Nguyen Templeton explore the chal-
lenges of listening to children in both classrooms and research that purports to center
young children. Through two stories from their respective studies, Yoon and Tem-
pleton highlight the complexities of following children’s leads given the competing
agendas situating the work of teachers and researchers in neoliberal contexts. Time
constraints, curricular mandates, and research expectations limit children’s valuable
contributions to their sociocultural communities. The authors’ goal is to discuss the
possibilities in taking up children’s words, gestures, and moves as knowledge. They
contend that children’s voices should not simply be heard for curricular purposes, for
adults’ amusement, to forward a neoliberal agenda, or to maximize our own goals
and pursuits. Instead, we should listen to understand the creativity and intelligence
of young children whose social worlds are meaningful.
Keywords: early childhood education, critical childhood studies, literacy, photography,
qualitative research, neoliberalism
Tran: [Your] mom told me a little bit about how school’s going for you . . .
Saryu: Did she tell you that we sit down so much?! [Taking on the teacher’s voice]
“Sit down on the rug, sit down on the chairs, sit down on the rug, sit down
on the rug!” And she doesn’t want us to talk, almost. Even when we’re play-
ing she wants us to be quiet and she wants us to whisper . . . Then we try
to get loud and then she hears us and she’s like, “Stop.” We have to. Then
she claps. Then we have to follow what she does, and then she says, “K–2,
it’s getting very noisy!”