Introduction
The use of PBSC transplantation (PBSCT) in allogeneic
transplantation is continuing to increase [1]. Initial studies
[2–5] showed improved engraftment kinetics when com-
pared with BMT and this has now been confirmed by several
other reports [6–9]. In addition, there is evidence to suggest
that the incidence of acute GvHD is not increased follow-
ing PBSCT, despite the infusion of much greater numbers
of T cells [7, 9–12]. However several non-randomized comp-
arisons of recipients of PBSCT and BMT have suggested
that there may be an increased incidence of chronic
GvHD following unmanipulated allogeneic PBSCT
[13–16]. This is associated with a concern that there may
be a concomitant increase in morbidity and mortality
associated with use of PBSC for allogeneic transplantation.
In contrast, there is evidence to suggest from a recent
IBMTR/EBMT analysis that overall survival may be
improved in patients with advanced leukemia following
allogeneic PBSCT because of a reduction in transplant-
related mortality [6]. Evidence suggests that the
Cytotherapy (2000) Vol. 2, No. 6, 423–428
423
© 2000 ISHAGE
An analysis of the effect of chronic GvHD on
relapse and survival following allogeneic PBSC
transplantation
G Miflin
1
, NH Russell
1
, I Franklin
2
, G Cook
2
, DW Milligan
3
, RM Hutchinson
4
,
MN Potter
5
, GJ Morgan
6
, A Pagliuca
7
, J Marsh
8
and A Bell
9
Departments of Haematology,
1
Nottingham City Hospital, Nottingham;
2
Glasgow Royal Infirmary, Glasgow;
3
Birmingham Heartlands
Hospital, Birmingham;
4
Leicester Royal Infirmary, Leicester;
5
Bristol Children’s Hospital, Bristol;
6
Leeds General Infirmary, Leeds;
7
Kings’ College Hospital, London;
8
St George’s Hospital, London;
9
Poole Hospital, Poole, Dorset, UK
Correspondence to : Professor NH Russell, Department of Haematology, Nottingham City Hospital, Hucknall Road, Nottingham NG5
1PB, UK.
Background
PBSC are increasingly being used as the source of stem cells in allo-
geneic transplantation. An increased incidence of chronic GvHD has
been suggested following unmanipulated allogeneic PBSC transplanta-
tion (PBSCT), however, how this affects overall survival is not yet
clear. Our aim was to study the impact of chronic GvHD on survival
and relapse following allogeneic PBSCT.
Methods
We have analyzed data from 73 patients undergoing HLA-matched
allogeneic PBSCT. GvHD prophylaxis was with CYA and MTX in
97% of patients. We have studied the incidence of chronic GvHD and
its affect on relapse and survival in these patients. All patients were at
least 100 days post-transplant at the time of analysis.
Results
Seventy-three patients were evaluable for analysis of chronic GvHD.
The overall incidence of chronic GvHD was 55% (limited in 18% and
extensive in 37%). Overall median survival was 991 days, with a 4 year
survival rate of 48%. Twelve patients relapsed. Patients with chronic
GvHD had a significantly lower incidence of disease relapse (p =0.005)
with a relapse probability of 8% at 3 years, compared with 40% in
patients with no chronic GvHD. In addition, the extent of chronic GvHD
had a marked effect on survival, patients with limited chronic GvHD had
a 4 year survival rate of 83%, compared with 45% in patients with
extensive chronic GvHD and 38% in patients with no chronic GvHD.
This difference was primarily due to the low incidence of relapse and low
mortality seen in patients with limited chronic GvHD.
Discussion
The presence and extent of chronic GvHD is an important predictor
of outcome following allogeneic PBSCT, in that patients who developed
either limited or extensive chronic GvHD had a low risk of disease
relapse.
Keywords
allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplantation, chronic graft-
versus-host disease, survival.