https://doi.org/10.1177/0022057419843523
Journal of Education
2019, Vol. 199(1) 45–56
© 2019 Trustees of Boston University
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/0022057419843523
journals.sagepub.com/home/jex
Original Research Report
Introduction
This article presents the major findings of a longitudinal
study that was conducted in 2014 to 2015, based on the con-
clusions of a previous pilot research (2013-2014), on the
examination, assessment, and enhancement of photograph-
based assignments aimed at improving the use of higher-
order thinking and language skills among second- and
fifth-grade students.
Higher-Order Thinking, Higher-Order Thinking
Skills, and Strategies
Higher-order thinking occurs when new information or
information that resides in the working memory (WM) is
being used to enhance, reorganize, and connect with previ-
ously existing knowledge through metacognition, transfer-
ence, and finding answers and solutions to problems and
complicated situations (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001;
Brookhart, 2010). Higher-order thinking skills include syn-
thesizing, analyzing, reasoning, comprehending, applica-
tion, and evaluation (Bloom, 1956).
The strategies for higher-order thinking are “focused
cognitive activities” (Yoad et al., 2009, p. 9), which include
among others—making comparisons, analysis and synthe-
sis, making assumptions, raising questions, reasoning, ana-
lyzing perspectives/exploring viewpoints, and abstraction
(Barahal, 2008; Zohar & Dori, 2009). The origin of the term
can be seen in the early ideas of Dewey (1933) regarding
the importance of reflection and thinking (1933), in Bloom’s
(1956) later theories and the actualized version of Anderson
& Krathwohl (2001)—the taxonomy that provides a defini-
tion from lower-order thinking (knowledge and memory) to
higher-order (synthesis evaluation and creation), in refer-
ence to the theories of Vygotsky and Piaget (Piaget, 1974;
Vygotsky, 1978, 1986).
Using higher-order thinking strategies can help students
develop language skills by encouraging them to monitor
their own answers (Block & Israel, 2004), which enhances
and encourages them to take ownership of new knowledge.
Language and higher-order thinking skills are intertwined.
Advance writing skills, for example, include components
of higher-order thinking such as critical thinking, evalua-
tion, and research (Lyon & Weiser, 2013). Higher-order
thinking skills help extend students’ vocabulary and sen-
tence-level skills including knowledge of grammatical
structure, understanding of descriptions, and the ability to
describe (Alves & Haas, 2012). The latter include skills of
understanding propositions and comprehension monitor-
ing, which also uses WM enabling extracting information,
generalization, abstraction, and interpretation based on the
843523JEX XX X 10.1177/0022057419843523Journal of EducationGil-Glazer et al.
research-article 2019
1
Tel-Hai Academic College, Upper Galilee, Israel
2
University of Haifa, Israel
Corresponding Author:
Ya’ara Gil-Glazer, Department of Education, Tel-Hai Academic College,
Upper Galilee 1220800, Israel.
Email: ygilglaz@gmail.com
PhotoLingo—Development and Improvement
of Higher-Order Thinking and Language Skills
Through Photographs
Ya’ara Gil-Glazer
1
, Ofra Walter
1
, and Billie Eilam
2
Abstract
This article presents the major findings of a longitudinal study on the use of photograph-based assignments to improve
higher-order thinking and language skills among second- and fifth-grade students using an intervention framework and a
convergent mixed method (quantitative and qualitative) approach. The method promoted oriented study skills for students
with an accent in the combination of higher-order thinking strategies, reading skills, and photo-elicitation. Participants in
the second grade attained a level close to participants in the fifth grade. Students with different levels of language skills in
the intervention group progressed significantly compared with the control group.
Keywords
higher-order thinking, language skills, photo-elicitation, visual literacy, photographs