Open Access. © 2023 the author(s), published by De Gruyter. This work is licensed under
the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110776478-009
Daniel Berounský
An Old Tibetan Myth on Retribution
for Killing the Nyen (Gnyan stong):
Manuscripts Scattered between Naxi,
Tanguts, Eastern and Western Tibet
Abstract: This chapter introduces eleven versions of a myth that appear in both
Tibetan and Naxi sources. The myth concerns the payment of retribution (stong)
for killing a type of non-human being known as Nyen (gnyan) by members of
a (human) Tibetan protoclan named Dong (Ldong). Six versions appear in Tibetan
sources, and five in Naxi manuscripts. The Tibetan sources in question are the
so-called Nyen Collection (Gnyan ’bum), of which four versions are available; the
Tö Collection (Gtod ’bum), of which we have one version; and finally, a manu-
script dealing with aquatic spirits Lu (klu) that was found in Gathang Bumpa
Stupa, southern Tibet. One of the five Naxi versions was paraphrased in English
by Joseph Rock in 1952. The fact that there are numerous surviving versions sug-
gests that this myth was once well-known in eastern Tibet. It also provides a link
between Naxi myths, East Tibetan non-Buddhist traditions, and West Tibet,
where two versions of the Nyen Collection were found.
1 Introduction
The present paper touches upon a fascinating, but very puzzling, topic of a certain
non-Buddhist mytho-poetic tradition related to eastern Tibet. This tradition is
found in an interesting corpus of myths known as the Nyen Collection (Gnyan
’bum), which was the subject of an article by Samten G. Karmay1 and two recent
contributions by myself.2 However, this lore apparently did not live in isolation:
the surviving corpus of myths, which features in the three known versions of the
Nyen Collection, is clearly not some ur-version that was immune to any changes:
the extant versions bear signs of amendations, as well as additions and compi-
lations from diverse sources. The Nyen Collection is related to three other large
1 Karmay 2010.
2 Berounsky 2016 and 2017.