The Laryngoscope
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
© 2006 The American Laryngological,
Rhinological and Otological Society, Inc.
Long-Term Follow-Up for Children Treated
With Surgical Intervention for
Chronic Rhinosinusitis
Rodney P. Lusk, MD; Marcella R. Bothwell, MD; Jay Piccirillo, MD
Objectives/Hypothesis: The goal of this study is to
retrospectively compare the long-term, 10 year, out-
comes of surgical versus medical management of
young children with chronic rhinosinusitis. Study
Design: This is a retrospective, age-matched, cohort
outcome study performed at a tertiary-care hospital.
Methods: Two groups of young children (2–5 yr old)
with chronic rhinosinusitis were treated with endo-
scopic sinus surgery or medically managed and eval-
uated 10 years after their initial therapy. Of the 131
eligible patients, 67 could be located and consented to
participate in the study. Six symptoms (day cough,
night cough, irritability or crankiness, headaches, na-
sal airway obstruction, and purulent rhinorrhea)
were used to assess the outcome of their treatment.
Results: Children undergoing endoscopic sinus sur-
gery had more significant disease as noted on the
computed tomography (CT) scans. Their symptom
severity, however, was similar. When individual
symptoms were compared, there were no statistically
significant differences between the surgically and
medically managed groups. When the mean was con-
trolled for baseline symptom severity and CT sever-
ity, there was statistical improvement in nasal airway
obstruction and decreased rhinorrhea. There was a
trend toward improvement in cough, but this was not
statistically significant. Parenteral assessment of im-
provement (change) in symptoms (P .001) and their
degree of satisfaction with treatment (P .005) was
significantly higher in the surgically managed group.
Conclusions: Children who have chronic rhinosinus-
itis improve in their symptoms of nasal airway ob-
struction and purulent discharge if they undergo
surgery. Parents of young children with chronic rhi-
nosinusitis appear to be more satisfied with the
outcome of surgical management than medical man-
agement when assessed 10 years later. Key Words:
Outcome assessment (health care), rhinosinusitis sur-
gery, endoscopic, chronic, rhinosinusitis, pediatric,
child.
Laryngoscope, 116:2099 –2107, 2006
INTRODUCTION
Pediatric rhinosinusitis is a frequent problem in chil-
dren, with a prevalence of approximately 8%, which is
more common than chronic diseases of the tonsils or ade-
noids affecting approximately 2% of children.
1
True rhi-
nosinusitis, as seen by primary care physicians, occurs
more commonly in the winter months.
1
Children with
rhinosinusitis are perceived by their parents to have sig-
nificantly more bodily pain and are more limited in their
physical activities than children with other chronic disor-
ders such as asthma and juvenile rheumatoid arthritis.
2
Pediatric rhinosinusitis, therefore, is a significant health
problem. Americans spend approximately $200 million on
prescription drugs and over $2 billion for over-the-counter
medications to treat rhinosinusitis.
3
The definition of rhinosinusitis has been controver-
sial, but most agree that acute rhinosinusitis can last up
to 30 days, and subacute rhinosinusitis can persist 30 to
90 days. The disease becomes chronic if there are persis-
tent symptoms for greater than 90 days.
4
These defini-
tions are useful but difficult to apply when recurrent viral
infections and acute rhinosinusitis are superimposed on
chronic rhinosinusitis.
The causes of recurrent acute or chronic pediatric
rhinosinusitis are multifactorial. Viral infections and al-
lergies are thought to be a major cause of recurrent acute
or chronic rhinosinusitis.
5
Viral rhinosinusitis is associ-
ated with a diffuse mucositis that is a precursor to approx-
imately 80% of bacterial sinus infections. Approximately
5% to 13% of patients with a viral infection progress to a
bacterial rhinosinusitis.
1,6
Viral infections are thought to
From the Departments of Pediatric Otolaryngology (R.P.L.), Boys’
Town National Research Hospital, Nebraska, U.S.A., the Department of
Otolaryngology (M.R.B.), University of Missouri Health Care, Colombia,
Missouri, U.S.A., and the Department of Otolaryngology (J.P.), Washington
University, St. Louis, Missouri, U.S.A.
Editor’s Note: This Manuscript was accepted for publication August
24, 2006.
Send correspondence to Dr. Rodney P. Lusk, Boys’ Town National
Research Hospital, NE. E-mail: luskr@boystown.org
DOI: 10.1097/01.mlg.0000244387.11129.a0
Laryngoscope 116: December 2006 Lusk et al.: Children Treated With Surgical Intervention for CRS
2099