Research Article
TFPPASV: A Three-Factor Privacy Preserving Authentication
Scheme for VANETs
Zongtao Duan ,
1
Jabar Mahmood ,
1
Yun Yang ,
1
Michael Abebe Berwo ,
1
Abd al Kader Ahmed Yassin ,
2
Muhammad Nasir Mumtaz Bhutta ,
3
and Shehzad Ashraf Chaudhry
3,4
1
School of Information and Engineering, Chang’an University, Xi’an 710064, China
2
Hatay Mustafa Kemal University (MKU) Turkish-Hatay/Hassa-MYO Girne, 79 Sokak, Hassa 31700, Turkey
3
Department of Computer Science and Information Technology, College of Engineering, Abu Dhabi University, Abu Dhabi, UAE
4
Department of Computer Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Architecture, Nisantasi University, Istanbul 34398, Turkey
CorrespondenceshouldbeaddressedtoYunYang;yangyun@chd.edu.cn
Received 25 May 2022; Revised 6 August 2022; Accepted 12 August 2022; Published 30 September 2022
AcademicEditor:AnMinFu
Copyright©2022ZongtaoDuanetal.isisanopenaccessarticledistributedundertheCreativeCommonsAttributionLicense,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Avehicularadhocnetwork(VANET)isessentialfortheautonomousvehicleindustry,andwiththeadvancementinVANET
technology,securitythreatsareincreasingrapidly.Mitigationofthesethreatsneedsanintelligentsecurityprotocolthatprovides
unbreakablesecurity.Inrecenttimes,variousthree-factorauthenticationsolutionsforVANETwereintroducedthatadoptthe
centralizedTrustedAuthority (TA),whichisresponsibleforassigningauthenticationparametersduringvehicleregistration,and
theauthenticationprocessdependsontheseparameters.isarticlefirstexplainsthevulnerabilitiesoftherecentthree-factor(3F)
authenticationschemepresentedbyXuetal.OuranalysisprovesthatifanRSUisdishonest,itcaneasilybypassthe TA andcan
createasessionwithOBU.Furthermore,thispaperputsforwardanewschemethatprovidesthe3FauthenticationforVANETs
(TFPPASV) to resist RSU from bypassing the TA and to offer user privacy. e proposed scheme fulfills the security and
performance requirements of the VANET. We use BAN-Logic analysis to perform a formal security analysis of the proposed
scheme,inadditiontotheinformalsecurityfeaturediscussion.Finally,wecomparethesecurityandperformanceoftheproposed
TFPPASV with some recent and related schemes.
1. Introduction
Due to its dynamic structure and related advantages in-
cluding the realization of autonomous cars, increased road
safety,congestionavoidance,andsoon,thevehicularadhoc
networks (VANETs) are getting more popularity and are
beingconsideredastheonlyvehicularnetworkstructureof
thefuture.Inrecentyears,theroadtravelsafetyisalsobeing
considered as most important factor for transportation
industry and accordingly several technologies are being
developed. A general model of vehicular ad hoc network
(VANET)[1–3]isgiveninFigure1.VANETisasubbranch
of MANETs; intelligent transportation system (ITS) [4]
provides support to manage transportation efficiently on
roads.VANETconsistsofthreeparts[5].(i)On-boardunit
(OBU) [6]:OBUisinstalledinsidethevehicleatthetimeof
manufacture from the company side. e OBU stores the
information related to vehicle identity, vehicle password,
and other parameters necessary for registration and com-
munication; without this confidential information, the ve-
hiclecannotcommunicatetootherOBUsorroadsideunit
(RSU) [2].OBUcommunicatestootherOBUsorRSUson
the road using the dedicated short range communication
(DSRC)protocol[7–9].(ii)RSUisfixedalongsidetheroad;
RSU has more computational and communication power
than OBU. RSU provides the facilities to OBUs to com-
municatewithother OBUs ortocommunicatewithRSUvia
DSRC. In addition, OBU wants to communicate with
Hindawi
Security and Communication Networks
Volume 2022, Article ID 8259927, 15 pages
https://doi.org/10.1155/2022/8259927