Adaptive Super-Twist Control with Minimal Chattering Effect
Vadim I. Utkin, Alex S. Poznyak and Patricio Ordaz
Abstract— The, so-called, adaptive super-twist controller is
considered here. It contains the adaptive gain-parameter which
adjusts the level of a scalar control action on-line based on direct
measurements the "equivalent control" obtained by a first-
order low-pass filter. It is shown that the problems of the finite
time convergence and keeping a small chattering amplitude can
be handled simultaneously if the gain magnitude is reduced to
a minimal admissible level defined by the conditions for sliding
mode to exist. The suggested methodology is compared nu-
merically with another schemes of a gain-adaptation (including
σ-adaptation) showing a high effectiveness under a significant
level of uncertainties and external disturbances.
I. I NTRODUCTION
A. Brief survey
The basic idea of Adaptive Control Approach consists in
designing the systems exhibiting the same dynamic prop-
erties under uncertainty conditions based on utilization of
current information. It involves modifying the control law
used by a controller to cope with the fact that the parameters
of the system being controlled are slowly time-varying or
uncertain. Even more, adaptive control implies improving
dynamic characteristics while properties of a controlled plant
or environment are varying [1], [20]. Without adaptation
the original Sliding Mode Control (SMC) demonstrate
robustness properties with respect to parameter variations
and disturbances [22]. The first attempts to apply ideas of
adaptation in SMC were made in the 60’s [6], [7] and
[8]: the control efficiency was improved by changing the
position or equation of the discontinuity surfaces without any
information on a plant parameters. The design idea might
be formulated as follows: if sliding mode exists, then the
coefficients of switching plane can be varied to improve the
system dynamics. However those early publications did not
take in to account the main obstacle for SMC application
- the chattering phenomenon which is inherent in sliding
motions (see, for example, [2], [3] and [4]). The phenomenon
is well-known from literature on power converters and re-
ferred to as “ripple” [16]. Then the efforts of the researchers
were oriented to the application of adaptivity principles
to reduce the effect of chattering. Since the amplitude
of chattering is proportional to discontinuity magnitude in
control, one of possible adaptation methods is related to
reducing this magnitude to the minimum admissible value
dictated by the conditions for SM to exist. So, in [17] the
Vadim I. Utkin. is with Departament of Electrical and computer
Engineering Ohio State Unviversity, Columbus, ohio, 43210, USA
utkin@ece.osu.edu
Alex S. Poznyak and Patricio Ordaz are with Automatic Control
Departament, CINVESTAV-IPN, A.P. 14-740, C.P. 07360 Mexico D.F
apoznyak@ctrl.cinvestav.mx
control gain depended on the distance of system state to a
discontinuity surface. The tracks of adaptivity can be found
in the first publications about variable structure systems with
SM (see [22], [23]) with the control gain proportional the
system state. Similar ideas were developed later in [11]
with different algorithms of tuning a control gain. There
exist also adaptive SMC (ASMC) algorithms that allow
adjusting dynamically the control gains without knowledge
of uncertainties/perturbations bounds. In particular, several
adaptive fuzzy SMC algorithms were proposed. However,
they do not guarantee the tracking performance (see [15],
[19] or overestimate the switching control gains as in [10]).
Of course, another efficient tool to suppress chattering is the
application of state observers [5], but for this method the
plant parameters are assumed to be known.
B. Motivation and the design idea
In [17] and [21] the adaptation process with the varying
magnitude of the control gain terminates at the moment when
the sliding mode starts. In [11] the authors tried to con-
tinue the adaptation process during sliding mode estimating
equivalent control. However, none of the above algorithms
resulted in minimum possible value of the discontinuous con-
trol. Finding the solution of this problem under uncertainty
conditions is the objective of this paper. This leads to the
minimization of chattering effect.
C. Primitive example
We start with a simple example. It is evident that for the
first-order system
˙ x (t)= a + u
u = −ksign (x (t)) ,k> 0
(1)
with known range only 0 < |a|≤ a
+
of a constant parameter
a. If the value of a is unknown, the magnitude of control
is selected such that sliding mode exists for the all values
of unknown parameter k>a
+
. However if parameter a is
varying, the gain k can be decreased and as a result chattering
amplitude can be reduced. The objective of adaptation is
decreasing k to the minimal value preserving sliding mode,
if parameter a is unknown.
If the condition k>a
+
holds, then sliding mode with
x (t) ≡ 0 occurs and control in (1) should be replaced by the,
so-called, equivalent control [22] u
eq
for which the right-
hand side in (1) is equal to zero, namely,
˙ x (t)=0= a + u
eq
(2)
that leads to
k [sign (x (t))]
eq
= a (3)
2011 50th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control and
European Control Conference (CDC-ECC)
Orlando, FL, USA, December 12-15, 2011
978-1-61284-799-3/11/$26.00 ©2011 IEEE 7009