Discrete Mathematics 52 (1984) 177-198
North-Holland
THE STRUCTURE OF RECTANGLE FAMILIES
DIVIDING THE PLANE INTO MAXIMUM
NUMBER OF ATOMS
A. GYARFAS, J. LEHEL and Zs. TUZA
177
Computer and Automation Institute, Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1111 Budapest,
Hungary
Received 13 November 1983
Introduction
Let .s4 = {Al, ... 'An} be a family of sets. The elements X, y E Ai are called
equivalent if for every i, 1:::;; i :::;; n, x E Ai if and only if y E Ai. The equivalence
classes are called the atoms of the family d. Rado asked in [4] the following
question: what is the maximum number f(n, d) of atoms, where the maximum is
taken over families of n boxes in the d-dimensional Euclidean space. A box is a
parallelepiped with sides parallel to the coordinate axes. A family of n boxes is
extremal if it defines f(n, d) atoms. Rado showed that f(n, 1) = 2n -1. The
authors of the present paper proved that f(n, 2) = 2n
2
-6n +7 if n deter-
mined f(n, 3) asymptotically and gave upper and lower bounds for f(n, d) (see
[3]).
The present paper is devoted to the two-dimensional extremal families of boxes
which we call box diagrams. Our main result, Theorem 3.1, is the characterization
of box diagrams. It turns out that all box diagrams can be obtained by a slight
modification (peripheral lifting) from a basic type: the caterpillar construction
given in Section 2. Box diagrams defined by the caterpillar construction for n = 3
and n = 4 are shown in Figs. 6 and 9 in Section 2. We note that this characteriza-
tion describes the structure of box diagrams completely.
It is remarkable that one-dimensional extremal families have no structural
characterization. As proved in [3], these are interval families with connected
overlap graphs for which only a non-structural characterization is known (cf. [2]).
We show two consequences of the main result. The first one concerns the
enumeration of box diagrams: apart from axial symmetries, there are
combinatorially non-equivalent box diagrams for n;::: 3 (Theorem 3.2).
The second consequence of the main result is the characterization of simple box
0012-365X/84/$3.00 © 1984, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. (North-Holland)