American Journal of Educational Research, 2013, Vol. 1, No. 9, 396-405
Available online at http://pubs.sciepub.com/education/1/9/8
© Science and Education Publishing
DOI:10.12691/education-1-9-8
Changing the Image of Scientists among College
Students in Israel
Bar Varda
1,*
, Pasit Koren
2
, Edna Rubin
3
, Anne Gail Buck
4
1
Science education department, Hebrew university of Jerusalem
2
Israel Education ministry instruction and curriculum design
3
Achava Teacher College
4
Curriculum and Instruction Department, Indiana University Bloomington
*Corresponding author: barvarda@zahav.net.il
Received October 22, 2013; Revised November 09, 2013; Accepted November 17, 2013
Abstract With this study, we sought to address some deficiencies in the image of scientists held by pre-service
teachers in Israel. These include a few concerns for women scientists, as well as a lack of understanding about
fieldwork and contemporary scientific equipment. The study was carried out with two groups of pre-service science
students, mostly women. It was done through interference: following the web, meeting with experts and constructing
leaning materials for pupils by the participants. Research was in the form of one strand research using qualitative
methods. During the research, the image of women scientists changed considerably. Pre interference views were:
there are no women scientists and physics and astrophysics are not for women. Women scientists were described as
torn between family and work. In the post interference stage, a high appreciation for women scientists and their work
in all domains was observed, woman scientist were portrayed as relaxed, taking part in team work, doing field work,
and using specialized sophisticated equipment.
Keywords: scientist image, college students, active involvement, conceptual change
Cite This Article: Bar Varda, Pasit Koren, Edna Rubin, and Anne Gail Buck, “Changing the Image of
Scientists among College Students in Israel.” American Journal of Educational Research 1, no. 9 (2013): 396-405.
doi: 10.12691/education-1-9-8.
1. Introduction
Research has revealed that women remain very poorly
represented in the image of scientists held by college
students in Israel. A summary of former research supports
this statement [1,2,3]. In this former research, women
were hardly mentioned as scientists: only about 7% of the
drawings were of women and among scientists' suggested
names women appear at about 7-8% of the lists. Only one
or two women were mentioned for each group of about
100 undergraduate students [1,2]. Captions and free
writings in several groups referred to the scientist as a man
("the white mail with the lab coat and goggles"). This
information was collaborated by the reasons given for not
becoming a scientist, such as "being a scientist causes
harm to the family", mostly attributed to: "the woman
needs to stay at home and take care of her family". Early
marriage and other traditional customs in Israel were also
mentioned [1]. Some of these reasons were heard mostly
among participants coming from religious groups, but
were also found among secular pre-service student
teachers. Properties attributed to the scientist were: being
intellectual (clever, wise), dedicated and diligent:
"working long hours in the lab doing experiments"; lonely:
"does not spend time with friends and not with his family".
Other properties attributed to the scientists were remote,
objective and creative. Students said that these properties
are typical to males [4]. Drawing captions and essay
writing gave the participants a chance to express their
views freely and not as answers to forced suggestions
revealed their true views. Open tools reinforced the data of
the closed tools such as draw, names and properties. A
survey of sources of knowledge used at school, about men
and women scientists, revealed a deficiency of women
names; women scientist are less mentioned than male
scientists in science text books and other leaning materials
used by the pupils of the future teachers [1]. There is a gap
between women and men especially regarding prestigious
occupation, such as leadership, command, management,
science and medicine, and also concerning sport, religion
and army, when the ratio of women to men is one to four.
The male is characterized as outgoing, creative, taking
part in many occupations among them science, and
possessing the role of a leader. Women are still depicted
as performing house hold chores. The positive properties
attributed to men in those text books, are being strong,
diligent, accurate, intelligent similar to the properties
attributed to scientists [1,5]. The students noted these
properties when describing why women are not willing or
not able to be scientists. Limited knowledge about
women's roles in science, and the lack of women role
models in science, might explain the lack of motivation of
women to work in science [3,5,6].