©
2015 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim 1 wileyonlinelibrary.com
COMMUNICATION
Highly Efficient Hybrid Photovoltaics Based on
Hyperbranched Three-Dimensional TiO
2
Electron
Transporting Materials
Khalid Mahmood, Bhabani Sankar Swain, and Aram Amassian*
Dr. K. Mahmood, Prof. A. Amassian
Physical Sciences and Engineering Division, and Solar
and Photovoltaic Engineering Research Center
King Abdullah University of Science and
Technology (KAUST)
Thuwal 23955–6900, Saudi Arabia
E-mail: aram.amassian@kaust.edu.sa
Dr. B. S. Swain
School of Advanced Materials Engineering
Kookmin University
Seoul 136–702, South Korea
DOI: 10.1002/adma.201500336
Seed-induced multistep and one-step hydrothermal methods
have been successfully used by Lee et al.
[31]
and Wu et al.
[15]
to
fabricate hyperbranched TiO
2
nanostructures with improved
light harvesting in DSSCs owing to their larger surface area.
However, these synthesis methods have resulted in a low den-
sity of nanofibers,
[15,31]
and have suffered from slow carrier
transport due to the presence of structural defects, including
at grain boundaries between the nanofiber trunks and nanorod
branches of the hyperbranched ETM. Electrospinning of metal
oxide nanofibers has recently emerged as a potentially inexpen-
sive, rapid, facile, and versatile route to growing 1D TiO
2
nano-
materials on a variety of substrates,
[40,41]
and has been investi-
gated as a 1D material in the context of DSSCs.
[42–44]
However,
the combination of electrospun TiO
2
fibers with hydrothermally
grown TiO
2
branches has not been investigated in the contexts
of DSSCs or PSCs.
[45]
In this communication, we introduce a unique and scal-
able multistage electrospinning and hydrothermal route for
the development of 3D hyperbranched anatase TiO
2
nanorod–
nanofiber arrays as electron transporting materials. The hyper-
branched ETM with optimal electron transport and carrier
lifetime leads to highly efficient mesostructured perovskite
(CH
3
NH
3
PbI
3
) solar cells with an average power conversion
efficiency (PCE
avg
) of 15.03% and a maximum power conver-
sion efficiency (PCE
max
) of 15.50%. Increasing the thickness
of the hyperbranched ETM from 0.6 μm to ≈29 μm led to
highly efficient DSSCs as well, with PCE
max
= 11.22%. These
remarkable performances were possible thanks to the develop-
ment of 3D hyperbranched nanofiber–nanorod arrays made
of high quality anatase TiO
2
with few defects and capable of
transporting electrons rapidly and over long distances, mini-
mizing recombination losses. Light harvesting was also found
to be significantly enhanced due to light scattering effects of the
hyperbranched architecture, leading to significant performance
boosts in DSSCs. This work demonstrates remarkable advan-
tages in using hyperbranched ETMs for highly efficient, large-
area, and low-cost hybrid photovoltaics.
In Figure 1a, we show scanning electron micrographs (SEM)
of nanofibers obtained by electrospinning of a first layer without
subsequent hydrothermal synthesis of nanorod branches
(E
1
H
0
). We have carefully selected the electrospinning condi-
tions, such as the applied voltage, the solution viscosity, and
flow rate, in order to obtain nanofibers assembled from small
TiO
2
nanoparticles (40–50 nm diameter) and exhibiting signifi-
cant internal porosity within the nanofibers (see the Supporting
Information). The formation of mesoporous nanofibers is also
an important requirement to obtaining hierarchically meso-
structured nanofiber–nanorod arrays during the subsequent
Solution-processed hybrid thin film photovoltaic technologies,
such as perovskite solar cells (PSCs), dye sensitized solar cells
(DSSCs), and colloidal quantum dot solar cells rely heavily on
TiO
2
as the electron transporting material (ETM), with organic
solar cells now also making use of the material as electron
transporting layer (ETL).
[1–9]
In the particular cases of DSSCs
and mesostructured PSCs, the ETL is typically engineered to
be mesoporous in order to promote a large surface area, good
loading of the absorber and to provide a continuous pathway
for electron transport and extraction with minimal recombi-
nation.
[10–13]
One-dimensional (1D) TiO
2
nanostructured ETLs
(nanotubes, nanorods, and nanowires) were recently shown to
provide larger internal surface area than the nanoparticulate
structure, promoting higher loading of absorber and distinct
light-scattering effects.
[14–21]
1D nanostructured ETLs have also
been found to offer efficient charge separation and electron
transport,
[10,22]
making them promising candidates for efficient
mesoporous PSCs and DSSCs. However, practical efforts to fab-
ricate PSCs and DSSCs based on 1D TiO
2
(anatase) nanowire
or nanotube arrays have not yielded performance improve-
ments to date.
[23–27]
Substantial further developments are needed in the archi-
tecture of mesostructured ETMs in order to achieve important
photovoltaic performance improvements in conditions compat-
ible with scalable manufacturing. We take the view that three-
dimensional (3D) hyperbranched nanowire architectures with
high surface area, low defect density, and a 3D interconnec-
tion network for electron extraction can be the basis of effec-
tive ETMs for mesostructured photovoltaics. Efforts have been
deployed to develop 3D hierarchical branched nanowire archi-
tectures,
[28–35]
as these are of great interest to a wide range of
applications including photocatalysis, energy storage, and pho-
tovoltaics.
[36–38]
Different methods of synthesizing 3D hyper-
branched TiO
2
nanowires have included vapor deposition,
[29]
pulsed-laser deposition,
[39]
and hydrothermal methods.
[24]
Adv. Mater. 2015,
DOI: 10.1002/adma.201500336
www.advmat.de
www.MaterialsViews.com