https://doi.org/10.1177/1532708619885404
Cultural Studies ↔ Critical Methodologies
1–14
© 2019 SAGE Publications
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/1532708619885404
journals.sagepub.com/home/csc
Original Article
First-year public school teachers often hear the echo of stu-
dent voices calling out, “Teacher! Teacher!” as they wrestle
with culture shock in their new positions. Teaching is a
complex profession, and teachers often report they do not
feel prepared to meet the demands of the job (Ingersoll,
2001). Research suggests the need for teachers is balloon-
ing, the supply is greening, and the profession is becoming
less stable (Ingersoll, Merrill, & Stuckey, 2018; Sutcher,
Darling-Hammond, & Carver-Thomas, 2016). There are
high turnover rates; many incoming teachers leave the pro-
fession after 2 to 5 years. This impacts student perfor-
mance, especially in schools serving underprivileged or
students of color (Darling-Hammond, 2010; Mantle-
Bromley, Gould, McWhorter, & Whaley, 2000). Hawaiʻi is
no exception with its high attrition rate among teachers.
Hawai‘i’s Department of Education recruits teachers from
the U.S. continent who experience problems adapting to
the culture, especially in rural areas (Pape & Terell, 2016).
These new comers rarely remain after 5 years, thus per-
petuating a cycle of teacher shortage.
In response to this problem, this applied theater project
took on the culture of first-year teaching in Hawai‘i by
integrating research and performance. Applied theater
operates in nontraditional spaces outside of conventional
theater forms, deliberately engaging communities in the
challenges they face while stimulating dialogue about pos-
sibilities and solutions. Boundaries between actors and
audiences are sometimes blurred as the community itself
takes an active role in the creative process. We employed
ethnodrama to transform interview transcripts into a cre-
ative product. Through a combination of ethnography and
performance, “we learn something about ourselves from
taking the role of others” (Turner, 1979, p. 82).
The project began with ethnographic interviews of 18
first-year teachers including elementary school teachers
(8), secondary teachers (5), and special educators (5). Next,
an ensemble of seven performers from the community
worked with two co-directors to interpret excerpts of the
transcripts and created a series of dances, poems, mono-
logues, and dramatic vignettes utilizing playbuilding strat-
egies (Tarlington & Michaels, 1995). Norris (2010) and
Saldaña (2011) have advanced playbuilding as a powerful,
collaborative method for effectively transforming research
transcriptions on the page into breathing action on stage.
The project culminated in three, hour-long performances
for audiences of teacher candidates and teacher educators,
885404CSC XX X 10.1177/1532708619885404Cultural Studies <span class="symbol" cstyle="symbol">↔</span> Critical MethodologiesSimpson Steele et al.
research-article 2019
1
University of Hawai‘i at Ma ¯noa, Honolulu, USA
2
Freelance Artist
3
Moanalua High School, Honolulu, US
Corresponding Author:
Jamie Simpson Steele, University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa, College of
Education, 1776 University Ave., Honolulu, HI 96816, USA.
Email: jamiesim@hawaii.edu
Teacher! Teacher! An Artistic
Exploration of the True-Story
Troubles and Triumphs of
First-Year Teachers
Jamie Simpson Steele
1
, Nicholas Brown
2
, Ronnie Tiffany-Kinder
1
,
Chloe Amos
2
, Andy Luu
1
, Neil O’Brien
2
, Mark Lester Ranchez
2
, Jill Tengan
3
,
Audrey Castañeda Walker
1
, and Judithanne Young
1
Abstract
New teachers often feel unprepared to meet the demands of the profession, and attrition rates indicate approximately half
will leave within their first 5 years. To address this problem, this applied theater project utilized ethnodrama, integrating
research and performance, to stage the stories of first-year teachers. Researchers interviewed 18 first-year teachers and an
ensemble of performers then developed a series of monologues, dances, poems, songs, and scenes. These vignettes fit within
three categories: (a) The Beginning; (b) The Students; and (c) The Profession. This script documents that performance.
Keywords
ethnodrama, applied theater, playbuilding, teacher preparation, teacher retention, novice teachers