Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jngse
An experimental study of the effective parameters on automatic line-break
control valves action in natural gas pipelines
Mehdi Mahmoodi
*
, Mofid Gorji Bandpy
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Babol Noshirvani University of Technology, Babol, Iran
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Automatic control valve
Line-break
Gas pipeline
Operating pressure
Orifice diameter
Pressure drop rate
ABSTRACT
The automatic line-break control valve (LBV) is a robust self-contained pipeline monitoring system which is
widely used to prevent gas releasing upon rupture or large leakage event in the oil and gas pipelines. The
differential pressure set point (DPS) at each valve location is the main criteria for value setting in LBV action. If
the DPS is not properly adjusted, the LBV may mistakenly close or it may not take any action at proper time. In
this study, the effect of characteristic parameters such as orifice diameter (OD), pipeline operational pressure
(POP) and pipeline pressure drop rate (ROD) due to rupture or major leak was experimentally investigated on
DPS. 100 different conditions with triple set of typical mentioned characteristic parameters were chosen. For
each condition, the differential pressure (DP) was measured over 180 s by statistically analyzing the experi-
mental results. Therefore, 100 maximum DP values (DPSs) were obtained. The attainable time to DPS depends
only on OD and is independent of the POP and ROD and decreases by increasing the OD. The DPS increases by
increase in ROD or decreasing OD or POP parameters. Because of using nitrogen gas instead of natural gas due to
safety reasons and the uncertainties, the DPS results can be practically applied by adding a safety factor of
10%–15%. Finally, the diagram of DPS with respect to ROD was provided for different POPs and ODs. The
diagram can be used as a basis for designing and regulating of LBVs installed on gas transportation pipelines.
1. Introduction
Automatic line-break control valves are installed on oil and gas
pipelines for several reasons. For example, LBVs can be used in zones
with no access to national electricity network, hazardous or impassable
area enclosure, passive defence conditions or to protect different eco-
systems such as rivers, ground waters and fertile lands. The goal of LBV
installation is automatic operation, remote control or required large
force for changing the control valve position (Nesbitt, 2011; Zhang,
2010). The rupture or leak detection ability depends significantly on
transmission system configurations, operating transients and philo-
sophy, which means that the selection of any detection system must be
based on a thorough analysis of the pipeline system (Chan, 1980).
Millions of liters of oil and gas are transported through pipelines each
day. Inaccurate or incorrect operation of LBVs can cause huge disaster
in pipelines. The high cost of required experimental testing, sensitive
design, passive defense and strategic role of LBVs are the reasons for
few reliable experimental data in this field. Several studies on leak
(Harriott, 2011; Noguerol, 2011; Reddy et al., 2011; Yan et al., 2015;
Chen et al., 2017; Ebrahimi-Moghadam et al., 2016) and ruptures de-
tection (AL-Rasheed et al., 2010; Lacerda and Elias, 2010; Peekema,
2013; Richards, 2013) in gas pipelines have been reported. However,
there are only a few studies on setting the DPS value of LBVs (Wang and
Zhang, 2004; Doostaregan, 2013; Wang et al., 2013) especially about
how the value settings might differ between gas pipelines.
The LBV requires detailed and accurate setting due to great sensi-
tivity on the rate of pressure variation over time in different pipeline
conditions. The pressure drop rate due to frictional losses in a piping
configuration is called normal pressure drop rate. This pressure drop
should not cause the LBV to act. The maximum differential pressure
between two sides of diaphragm valve is DPS. LBV will be regulated
with certain DPS for different conditions. As mentioned, DP depends on
several parameters such as POP, ROD and OD. The orifice in line-break
detection system is the most important section of a LBV. Sensible
pressure drop occurs by a pipeline rupture or large leak. The corre-
sponding ROD can be observed at the adjacent control valve location.
The DPSs of LBV are usually adopted based on experience or estimated
values derived from pipeline steady flow over a long time (Lorusso,
2012; Phan and Sawin, 2012; Zuo et al., 2015).
In this study, the effect of critical parameters such as POP, ROD and
OD on DPS of LBV with a Scotch-yoke actuator were experimentally
studied. Understanding the effects of these parameters is critical to
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jngse.2018.01.006
Received 18 February 2017; Received in revised form 4 January 2018; Accepted 4 January 2018
*
Corresponding author. P.O.Box 484, Babol University of Technology, Babol, Mazandaran, Iran.
E-mail address: mmahmoodi@stu.nit.ac.ir (M. Mahmoodi).
Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering 52 (2018) 59–81
1875-5100/ © 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T