Nuclear Engineering and Design 237 (2007) 575–590
Numerical simulation of turbulent flow in a 37-rod bundle
D. Chang, S. Tavoularis
∗
Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Ottawa, 770 King Edward Avenue, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada K1N 6N5
Received 14 December 2005; received in revised form 31 July 2006; accepted 1 August 2006
Abstract
The unsteady Reynolds averaged Navier–Stokes equations, combined with a Reynolds stress model, were solved numerically to determine fully
developed isothermal turbulent flow in a 60
◦
sector of a 37-rod bundle. It was found that this flow contained large-scale coherent structures, which
affected strongly the local velocity fluctuations, especially near the gaps between rods or between rods and the surrounding wall. The time-averaged
mean velocity and Reynolds stresses were in good agreement with experimental results in a similar channel. Coherent velocity fluctuations at
different locations throughout the entire rod bundle were strongly correlated with each other.
© 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Rod bundles are essential elements of pressurized water
nuclear reactors. They consist of tightly packed arrays of rods,
which contain the nuclear fuel and are surrounded by flowing
liquid coolant. Flow phenomena in the subchannels bounded
by adjacent rods or outer rods and the containing pressure tube
walls are quite complex and exhibit patterns not present in pipe
flows. In particular, rod–rod and rod–wall gap regions are char-
acterized by strong transverse flow pulsations, which are largely
responsible for momentum and heat transfer across the gaps. It
is widely accepted that these flow pulsations are associated with
large-scale vortices, which form quasi-periodically in pairs on
either side of the gap (Hooper and Rehme, 1984; Rehme, 1992;
Krauss and Meyer, 1998; Guellouz and Tavoularis, 2000a) and
can be classified as coherent structures (Hussain, 1983).
In general, previous simulations of turbulent flows in rod bun-
dles have assumed that the flow field is stationary and solved
the Reynolds averaged Navier–Stokes equations (RANS) using
conventional gradient-transport-type turbulence models (e.g.,
Rapley and Gosman, 1986; Baglietto and Ninokata, 2005). Such
simulations have achieved a limited agreement with experi-
ments only by the direct use of empirical information applicable
to the specific geometry (Wu, 1994; Baglietto and Ninokata,
2005). The use of RANS with general-purpose turbulence mod-
∗
Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 613 562 5800x6271; fax: +1 613 562 5177.
E-mail address: tav@eng.uottawa.ca (S. Tavoularis).
els without specific adjustments has provided poor predictions.
For example, Lee and Jang (1997) performed numerical sim-
ulations for a rod bundle flow using a non-linear k–ε model
without any adjustments to conclude that this approach strongly
underestimated the strong azimuthal turbulence intensity mea-
sured by Hooper (1980). Yadigaroglu et al. (2003) conducted
an in-depth review of rod bundle numerical simulations, iden-
tifying the needs of light water reactor safety analyses. They
summarized the numerical simulations of Tzanos (2001) in a
square-lattice rod bundle and concluded that gradient-transport
models, like the k–ε model, are not adequate to predict turbulent
flow in the narrow gap regions.
Most previous simulations of rod bundles have considered
periodic arrays of rods, only solving the flow in elementary
sections of such arrays and assuming symmetry across the
boundaries (Rapley and Gosman, 1986; Lee and Jang, 1997;
Baglietto and Ninokata, 2005). This approach greatly restricts
the solution, because, although the geometric configuration may
be symmetric, the flow itself may not be so, particularly as
it is known to oscillate across gaps. Moreover, most numeri-
cal studies have been conducted for either triangular or square
subchannels, which may not be representative of entire rod bun-
dles. For example, the 37-rod bundle of the CANDU reactor
has three different kinds of subchannels, triangular, square and
wall subchannels. Full bundle simulations are required to cap-
ture possible interactions among different types of subchannels.
In a recent article (Chang and Tavoularis, 2005), we have pre-
sented detailed numerical simulations of isothermal turbulent
flow in a rectangular duct containing a single rod, a configu-
0029-5493/$ – see front matter © 2006 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.nucengdes.2006.08.001