INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SCIENTIFIC & TECHNOLOGY RESEARCH VOLUME 9, ISSUE 09, SEPTEMBER 2020 ISSN 2277-8616
231
IJSTR©2020
www.ijstr.org
Effectiveness Of A Selected Mean Filter
Algorithm To Reduce Noise In Fluoroscopy
Images
Jhon Hadearon Saragih, Choirul Anam, Wahyu Setia Budi, Ummu Mar'atu Zahro, Geoff Dougherty
Abstract : This study aims to implement noise reduction algorithm with a selected mean filter (SMF) and to investigate its computation time in the
denoising process on X-ray fluoroscopy images. The SMF was the mean filter (MF) technique, but in its application, selected pixels within threshold
value were only used to calculate the average pixel value. The effectiveness of SMF was then compared to well-known filters, such as adaptive mean
filter (AMF) and bilateral filter (BF). The notebook of Acer Nitro 5 Intel Core i5-8300H 2.3 GHz with 8GB RAM, Graphic Processor Unit (GPU) Nvidia
Geforce GTX 1050 4GB, and the Windows 10 Home operating system with SSD M.2 NVMe 2280 256GB were utilized. The algorithm was implemented
using Matlab R2019b. The fluoroscopy images of NEMA SCA & I Cardiovascular Fluoroscopic Benchmark Phantom with size of 512 x 512 pixels were
filtered, exposure factors of 69.92 kV and 583 mA and a dose-area product (DAP) of 1,660 mGy-cm
2
with a field of view (FOV) of 25 cm. In addition,
image quality of the filtered images was assessed, including noise level, signal-to-noise ratio (SNR), contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR), and spatial resolution.
The results showed that by using the SMF, the higher improvement of image quality in terms of noise level, SNR, CNR, and spatial resolution compared
to AMF and BF, was achieved. The time needed by SMF to process an image was about 0.36 seconds, while the AMF and BF are 10.6 and 1.4 seconds,
respectively. The SMF was as fast as a traditional MF, which only need 0.33 seconds for an image.
Index Terms : Selected Mean Filter, Noise Reduction, Fluoroscopy, Cardiovascular, Image Quality, Radiation
—————————— ——————————
1. INTRODUCTION
FLuoroscopy plays an important role in medical imaging, and
has been widely used in the clinical examination of patients
and in intervention procedures (angiography). Fluoroscopy
employs ionizing radiation so that it poses a potential danger
to patients [1], despite its benefits as a gold standard for
diagnosis in many cases. Exposure to ionizing radiation must
always be kept as low as reasonably achievable (ALARA), by
providing the minimum amount of radiation required in order to
provide useful diagnostic results [2].
Reducing radiation exposure is an essential challenge related
to fluoroscopy X-ray imaging. However, when the radiation
dose is minimized, the resulting high noise results in a reduced
image quality that leads to a decreased accuracy of clinical
diagnosis. Thus, some form of image denoising is required. A
noise reduction algorithm is considered as an effective
technique in reducing the dose received by patients [3], [4].
Previously, a study on non-linear filters showed that the
bilateral filter (BF) could denoise images without causing a
deterioration in the spatial resolution of the images [5]. It was
observed that the BF produced images of similar quality to
those from full-dose exposure, but with half the dose
exposure. The average time required to apply the BF to 512 x
512 pixels image using a portable computer (Intel processor
Core-2-due 2.6 GHz, RAM 4 GB, Cash Memory 3 MB) and a
MATLAB (version 7.12 R2011) implementation was about 25
seconds [5]. Similar studies on the effectiveness of BF
algorithm and other algorithms, such as adaptive mean filter
(AMF), have also been carried [6]–[10].
Available denoising algorithms require a heavy computational
burden and a long processing time, so that it is difficult to
implement them in clinical X-ray fluoroscopy which typically
results in 15-30 frames per second. This may be mitigated by
using high-speed computer technology or a more efficient
denoising algorithm. A selective mean filter (SMF) has been
proposed as a fast filter which reduces noise while maintaining
the spatial resolution of an image [11]. However, the algorithm
has only been implemented in computed tomography (CT)
images. The aim of this study is to implement SMF for X-ray
fluoroscopy images, and to investigate the resulting
computational time and image quality.
2 RESEARCH METHODS
2.1 SMF algorithm
The SMF was recently introduced and is based on the simple
mean filter technique. However, not all neighboring pixels are
used to calculate the average pixel value, rather it is done
selectively based on a threshold value (h). That is, if the
differences of the values of neighboring pixels in a kernel and
the central pixel are greater or smaller by a threshold value h,
then the neighboring pixel is not included in the selective
mean. The selection of pixels uses equation (1).
(1)
Noise reduction in the image is computed using the
equation (2),
(2)
————————————————
Postgraduate Program, Department of Physics, Faculty of
Sciences and Mathematics, Diponegoro University, Jl. Prof.
Soedarto SH, Tembalang, Semarang 50275, Central Java,
Indonesia. E-mail: jhonhsaragih.2019@fisika.fsm.undip.ac.id
Department of Physics, Faculty of Sciences and Mathematics,
Diponegoro University, Jl. Prof. Soedarto SH, Tembalang,
Semarang 50275, Central Java, Indonesia. E-mail:
anam@fisika.fsm.undip.ac.id