Female board directorship and
earnings management
Yosra Mnif
Department of Accounting, Taxation and Law, High Institute of Business
Administration of Sfax, Sfax, Tunisia, and
Imen Cherif
Faculty of Economics and Management, University of Sfax, Sfax, Tunisia
Abstract
Purpose – This paper aims to examine the impact of female board directorship on the extent of earnings
management.
Design/methodology/approach – The research hypotheses have been tested using both univariate and
multivariate analyzes based on a sample of 198 firm-year observations from closely-held family firms listed
on the SBF 120 over the period 2010–2018.
Findings – The empirical results first indicate that female board participation reduces the level of earnings
management. When looking at women positions in the companies’ boardrooms, the authors reveal that the
negative linkage between female board directorship and earnings management remains constant for
independent female directors while the opposite holds for their family-affiliated counterparts. Further, the
gender quota reform is shown to mitigate the adverse relationship between gender-diverse corporate boards
and the extent of earnings management. These results seem sound, as they hold unchanged for the several
measures of, both, boardroom gender diversity and earnings management used in the empirical study. In a
supplementary analysis, the authors provide evidence that the association between the presence of women
directors on the companies’ boards and earnings management depends, in a different way, on the size of the
audit firm in a joint auditing context.
Originality/value – The country and the period considered in this paper are noteworthy characteristics that
enhance the value of this research. The present study is relevant because it examines the relationship between
female boardroom participation and earnings management using a homogeneous sample of family-owned and
-managed companies within which shareholders and board members share identical motives for manipulating
earnings in one of the leading countries in the world with regard to family ownership dominance (i.e. France).
Moreover, this paper is considered to be very timely, as it explores, contrarily to previous related studies, the
years following the implementation of a mandatory gender quota reform in one of the less available countries, to
date, that have amended a gender quota law. To the knowledge, besides France, there are a few markets
(Norway, Belgium, Finland and Iceland) that have implemented such legislation.
Keywords Female board directorship, Earnings management, Closely-held family firms,
Gender quota reform
Paper type Research paper
1. Introduction
Following the announcement of major corporate financial scams by large institutions
around the globe (Enron and WorldCom in the USA; Transmile and Megan Media in
Malaysia and Parmalat in Italy), several accounting academics have delivered significant
attention to the issue of earnings management and financial reporting quality. Specifically,
The authors would like to thank the editor, professor Whiting, Ros, and two anonymous reviewers
for their helpful comments, suggestions and guidance on the article.
Female board
directorship
Received 28 April 2020
Revised 12 October 2020
5 November 2020
Accepted 7 November 2020
Pacific Accounting Review
© Emerald Publishing Limited
0114-0582
DOI 10.1108/PAR-04-2020-0049
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:
https://www.emerald.com/insight/0114-0582.htm