J. AM. ACAD CHILD ADOLESC. PSYCHIATRY, 39:10, OCTOBER 2000
1309
ABSTRACT
Objective: To report on a brief parent-child group therapy program for children with anxiety disorders. Method:
Twenty-four children with an anxiety disorder and their parents participated in a 1 O-session treatment.
Children were evaluated at pretreatment (T,), posttreatment (T2), 12-month follow-up (T3), and 36-month follow-
up (T4). Ten children were also assessed on entering a waiting period (To). Results: There were no significant
symptomatic changes between To and T,. Anxiety symptoms decreased significantly during the treatment and
follow-up periods. Depressive symptoms changed only during the follow-up period. The percentage of children
with no current anxiety disorder was 71 % at T2 and 91 % at T4' Children of mothers with an anxiety disorder
improved more than children of nonanxious mothers, whereas the anxiety level of anxious mothers remained
stable. Conclusions: Brief parent-child group psychotherapy may serve as a time-limited, cost-effective, and
efficient intervention. J. Am. Acad. Child Adolesc. Psychiatry, 2000. 39(10):1309-1312. Key Words: anxiety
disorder, parent-child, group psychotherapy.
Case Series: Brief Parent-Child Group Therapy for
Childhood Anxiety Disorders Using a Manual-Based
Cognitive- Behavioral Technique
PAZ TOREN, M.D., LEO \VOLMER, M.A., BATIA ROSENTHAL, M.A., SOFIA ELDAR, M.D., SHARON KOREN, B.A.,
MICHAL LASK, M.D., RONIT WEIZMAN, and NATHANIEL LAOR, M.D., PH.D.
Childhood anxiety causes marked distress and has implica-
tions for adult functioning (Kendall, 1992). The estimated
incidence of childhood anxiety disorders ranges from 5.7%
to 17.7% (Costello and A.'1gold, 1995), particularly
overanxious disorder (2.6%-15.4%), separation anxiety
disorder (5%), and simple phobia (5%). The higher prev-
alence of anxiety disorders in parents of children with
anxiety disorders than in parents of nonanxious children
(Last et al., 1991; Weissman, 1988) supports the assumptions
that family dynamics propagate morbidity and that genetic
load may magnify familial factors (Barrett et al., 1996).
Family and cognitive-behavioral individual psycho-
therapies have been proven effective in the treatment of
children with anxiety disorders (Beidel and Francis, 1995;
Kendall, 1994). However, economic restraints have prompted
research into more cost-effective interventions (family,
group, or integration of both) (Trad, 1994).
Accepted March 21,2000.
From the Tel Aviv-Brǘll Community Mental Health Center and the Sackler
School of Medicine, Tel-Aviv University, Israel (all authors), and the Yale Child
Study Center, New Haven, CT (DI: Lam).
Reprint requests to Dr Toren, Tel Aviv Community Mental Health Center,
9 Hatzvi Street, Tel-Aviv, 67197. Israel.
0890-8567/00/391O-I309©2000 by the American Academy of Child and
Adolescent Psychiatry.
Data on cognitive-behavioral family-group treatment yielded
a significant proportion of disorder-free children after
treatment (65%) and 12 months later (85%) (Barrett, 1998;
see also Mendlowitz et al., 1999).
The aim of this study is to present the results achieved
with our child-parent group treatment program.
METHOD
Subjects
Participants were 24 consecutive children (14 boys, 10 girls)
attending the Child and Adolescent Clinic of the Tel-Aviv
Community Mental Health Center and their 40 parents (8 single-
parent families). Children were 6 w 13 years old (mean ± SD =
9,6 ± 1.7 years) with a principal diagnosis of separation anxiety
disorder (52%), overanxious disorder (4%), or both (44%) and no
prior drug treatment. Children with neurological disorders or
mental retardation were excluded. Co-morbid conditions included
simple phobia (17%), attention-deficit/ hyperactivity disorder
(ADHD) (25%), chronic tics (12%), enuresis (8%), and minor
depressive disorder, mild obsessive-compulsive disorder, and
encopresis (4% each).
Twelve mothers (50%) had no anxiety disorder, 11 (46%) had
generalized anxiety disorder (one co-morbid with chronic minor
depressive disorder), and 1 (4%) had panic disorder. Thirteen
fathers (82%) had no anxiety disorder and one each (6%) had
major depressive disorder, major depressive disorder with organic
disorder, and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Families with a
Global Assessment of Relational
מאמר זה זכ לשנת ה בפרס המאמר המצטיי2000